Skip to content

Declawing is inhumane

Published:

By Robert K. Wrede Santa Monica

I write in strong support of the rapid passage of an ordinance banning the declaw-ing of pets in the city of Santa Monica, as a long overdue step in the eradication of an archaic, cruelly inhumane and socially unjustifiable practice.

I am a long-time practicing lawyer, an adjunct professor of law (at Pepperdine), a former officer in the paratroops, and a dedicated lover of nature, in general, and both domestic and wild animals, in particular. I also have insights gained representing business interests in the field of environmental regulation and appreciate the delicate balance that sometimes must be struck between serving legitimate human needs and the impact serving those needs might have on our environment and our fellow creatures. There is no such balance to be struck here.

In my opinion, the maiming of animals solely to feed the egos and serve the convenience of their all-powerful owner/guardians serves no legitimate human need whatsoever and simply cannot be justified, although those who perform such mutilations admittedly would be deprived of a small source of income were such an ordinance to be passed.

I have long been a responsible, loving pet-owner and strongly believe that those who are willing to maim their animals for the sake of their own vanity or convenience do not deserve the love, loyalty and companionship of such animals.

As responsible citizens of one of the wealthiest and most influential jurisdictions in the world, and members of the world’s most destructive species, we must assume a leadership role in protecting helpless animals from further abuse and depredation. Passage of an ordinance by the city of Santa Monica preventing the mutilation of house pets for non-medical reasons would clearly be a step in the right direction.

Animal declawing is outlawed by most industrialized nations and considered both inhumane and unnecessary by many experts like the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), the Association of Veterinarians for Animal Rights (AVAR), the Humane Society of the United States, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, In Defense of Animals, Animal Protection Institute, and Last Chance for Animals.

In addition to these well-known American organizations, the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons of Great Britain has gone on record, declaring that, “declawing is an unnecessary mutilation.” Removing the first digits from the feet of victimized animals is, indeed, “unnecessary mutilation” of the most despicable order.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 10, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe