By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
While the Republicans are visibly in trouble — former majority leader Tom Delay has been indicted on several criminal counts involving campaign contributions, Senate majority leader Bill Frist is under investigation for a questionable stock sale, and President Bush has earned some of the lowest approval ratings of his entire presidency (they’re hovering around 38-40 percent), their issues look minor compared with the Democrats.
The Democratic Party is structurally in trouble, which if it doesn’t overcome shortly, might lead to its demise as a functioning political party in the American system.
How can I predict such a dire outcome for one of the two major political parties? Because Democrats don’t appear to be learning from their electoral losses. And in politics, like in nature, species that don’t adapt to new circumstances, eventually become extinct.
What makes me say this? Mostly, two articles, which interviewed different leaders about the state of the Democratic Party.
One article on the Newsweek site, written by Howard Fineman was entitled: “Beltway vs. Blogosphere.” Fineman interviewed Simon Rosenberg, the director of the New Democratic Network, about the “mood” on the blogosphere. Rosenberg explained that most of the people on the Internet were disappointed with those in the Beltway. He said that generally they believe that the Democrats in Washington are not confrontational enough and that they compromise too often with the conservatives. While it is not purely a “liberal-not liberal enough” dynamic, much of the frustration stems from those in the blogosphere believing that those in the Beltway do not defend liberal issues courageously enough.
Fineman sees a civil war brewing. I see the end of the Democratic Party as we know it. Why?
Because of the other article I read, which was in Boston Globe and written by Scott Lehigh. Lehigh interviewed Al From, CEO and founder of the Democratic Leadership Council — the moderate faction of the Democratic Party from which President Bill Clinton rose to national leadership in the early 1990s. From explained that the ideological make-up of the electorate has changed dramatically over the past 40 years and now, “only 21 percent of the electorate … considers itself liberal, as opposed to 34 percent who call themselves conservatives. Forty-five percent say they are moderates.”
This is important because there are very few “flaming moderates” in the world. Not many moderates feel intensely passionate about being ideologically moderate (I’m an exception to the rule). As a result, intense debates — ones that are passionate and confrontational — scare most moderates. They tend to associate insanity with intensity. They tend to distrust passion and they tend to believe that underlying emotion is irrationality.
And this is important because ideologues at both ends of the spectrum tend to exhibit intensity towards the issues they believe in. Moreover, it is the lack of intensity among Beltway Democrats, which has got the Blogosphere Democrats in an uproar. However, if the Beltway Democrats capitulate to the Blogosphere Democrats, then they will surely turn off the moderates whom they need to win elections — 21 percent is not enough for a victory. Yet, if the Beltway Democrats ignore the Blogosphere Democrats, then they will likely lose at least some of their activist base, though it is doubtful that they would lose all 21 percent of it because where would they go?
Hence, irreconcilable differences exist between these factions of the party. The Blogosphere Democrats refuse to believe that there is anyone else in the country besides them, even while the Beltway Democrats are working towards winning a majority by appearing more temperate. The Republicans, of course, can get away with more heated rhetoric (read: ideologically extreme) because they have larger numbers and they don’t have to attract as many moderates to win a majority. Democrats need nearly twice as many moderate as Republicans to put together a majority — 29 percent versus 16 percent of moderates to reach the 50 plus 1 percent mark, given the above distribution.
The basic problem is that the Democrats are like the Whig Party in the 1850s. Prior to 1856, the Whigs were a vital party that stood for national improvements and programs. They had elected presidents, they had a nationwide presence, and they were the major opposition party to the Democrats. But they could not reconcile their Northern and Southern factions’ stances on slavery and they disappeared from politics when the Republican Party was created and most Northern Whigs (Abraham Lincoln included) joined them in 1860.
Here’s the Thing: If the Democrats don’t pick up seats in 2006 and they manage to lose the presidency in 2008, don’t be surprised if the Beltway Democrats leave the Blogo-sphere Democrats to themselves to form another “moderate” party that can win elections. Survival in politics is what matters. Adaptability, not ideology is king. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and teaches at California State University, Channel Islands. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 7, 2005. Read the original PDF.