By Greg Poirier Santa Monica
As one of the original backers of Prop. A, I am amazed and, I must say, grateful for the softball that Nina Fresco lobbed to us in her letter to the editor (SMDP, Oct. 20, page 4) objecting to homeowners exercising their constitutional rights by urging the ouster of Councilmembers Feinstein, Genser and Bloom. She gives us a chance to clear up some misconceptions.
First of all, she continues to repeat the outright lie that Prop. A was not a homeowner initiative, but instead was backed by some mysterious, nefarious developers which she cannot name. This is patently false, and no matter how many times she repeats it, it will still be false. Prop. A came about because literally hundreds of citizens attended Landmark Commission meetings every month for over a year and saw for themselves how the commission operates. It came about because citizens angered by their actions were summarily ignored, and we were frustrated. It was a citizen backed initiative, period, and it received 80 percent of the vote in the neighborhoods that would have been effected by their actions. The continued dismissal of the very existence of these homeowners by Ms. Fresco and the coun-cilmembers in question is exactly the reason Prop. A happened.
By the way, Ms. Fresco met me and another backer of Prop. A at Peete’s Coffee shortly after the election and asked us if the homeowners had any suggestions of how to make the system work better for us (we gave her several ideas, but... surprise... none of them have been implemented). I don’t think she would have had that cup of coffee with us if she really thought we were developers.
She also says that Bloom, Feinstein and Genser “called the election.” This is completely insane. Prop. A got on the ballot because we forced them to put it there, by gathering signatures. They did everything they could think of to keep it from a vote. “Called the election?” What color is the sky in her world?
She goes on to say that a “show of hands” would have closed the issue of an historic district on 18th Street. Well, 74 of the 118 homeowners on 18th Street came to their meetings month after month and said very clearly that we didn’t want it, but they plowed forward in spite of this. We were in that room speaking against it for so long that we saw Ms. Fresco go from not being pregnant to having a newborn. I guess our mistake was that we didn’t raise our hands.
Finally, the part of her letter that simply boggles the mind is when she accuses us of politicizing the preservation issue. It was her commission, along with Councilmembers Feinstein, Genser, Bloom and McKeown who did that when they sent out mailer after mailer to renters falsely claiming that Prop. A was a covert attack on rent control (be careful, they’ll be coming for you next). It was the sleaziest kind of politics, the politics of fear, and she and her council cohorts wallowed in it during the campaign. They also manipulated the process, changing the voting method to a mail in system, the one and only time that system has ever been used in the city (notice they aren’t using it for this election. I guess the fewer voters the better when their jobs are on the line).
I am not opposed to these candidates because they are backed by Santa Monicans For Renters’ Rights. I don’t care about SMRR one way or the other, I’m not a renter or a landlord. I am opposed to these three candidates because they screwed the city’s homeowners and continue to do so. Homeowners have not only a right, but an obligation to remember who stood with them and who stood against them when they go to the polls. Genser, Feinstein and Bloom (and McKeown) made it very clear that they intend to take an aggressively adver-sarial approach to Santa Monica’s homeowners. If we didn’t send a letter out and publish an ad urging voters to remember these councilmembers for their actions, not their words, we would be remiss in our duty to our neighbors. Ms. Fresco, it’s called democracy.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 22, 2004. Read the original PDF.