By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER
Alternative dispute resolution can be a superior way to solve contractual disagreements by avoiding the bureaucracy of our court system, and very often saving valuable time and money.
Generally, the first step in alternative dispute resolution is to mediate. Mediation is a non-binding negotiation between two parties led by a neutral party with expertise in the subject of the dispute but with no power to order a settlement. The mediator meets with each party separately to discuss their side of the dispute and then attempts to facilitate a mutually satisfying resolution. If no resolution , then binding arbitration is in order.
Arbitration is “purely a creature of contract between parties” and the provision included in a contract “amounts to a mutual waiver of the right to a civil trial,” according to John A. Sherril, JD.
An arbitration hearing is more formal than mediation and less formal than a court hearing. I have personally attended a mediation that was held in my attorney’s office and an arbitration hearing which was held in the conference room of the American Arbitration Association, both much less formal and stressful than a court room. An arbitration hearing is usually overseen by one arbitrator, or a panel of arbitrators who also has (have) exper-tise in the subject. After hearing arguments from both sides that person will make a binding decision on how the dispute will be resolved.
There are several good reasons to choose alternative dispute resolution instead of litigation but the most significant seems to be the ability to write a provision into a contract outlining how a possible future dispute will be handled, cus-tomizing it for each party’s needs, or as Sherril puts it, “the freedom to specify the rules of engagement may be alternative dispute resolution’s most appealing aspect.”
Mediation has an extra benefit in that a mediator can solve a dispute in a non-monetary or monetary way when, generally, a court’s or an arbitrator’s decision is dealt with from a monetary standpoint. Bernard Alexander, a principal in the law firm Alexander & Yong in Sherman Oaks said that an alternative dispute resolution can be advantageous because “a jury trial may be problematic in that you have a group of people who, most likely, have no expertise in the subject of the dispute with the potential to be unpredictable, risking an unreasonable decision, whereas a judge is more likely to view the dispute conservatively as a breach of contract issue with limited damages.” An alternative dispute resolution gives parties to the contract the ability to focus strictly on the subject at hand and not be detoured by the bureaucracy of our court system which, among other things, may require the extra time and expense of educating a jury.
On the flip side, there are difficulties with an alternative dispute resolution. Litigation involves counsel, requiring compliance with some kind of “quality assurance” regarding the credentials of the “professionals” involved in the proceedings, not allowing an inexperienced and reckless individual to represent a party. That’s unlike an dispute resolution proceeding, which requires a person’s qualifications be specified in the original contract in order to assure a qualified individual is chosen. Additionally, not having to pay an attorney may encourage frivolous claims.
According to Mark A. Senn, an expert in the negotiation and preparation of commercial real estate leases, some landlords discourage tenants from commencing unfounded arbitration by requiring that the arbitration be non-monetary — or an escrow of a disputed amount — as a condition to a tenant’s commencement of an arbitration or, set a cap on the amount that is arbitrable. For example: $50,000. Another point made by Senn is that if one of the parties refuses to arbitrate, you may end up in court after all, creating the very thing being avoided, and incurring delay and additional cost. You can get around this by stating in the original contract the consequences of non compliance, possibly giving power to the arbitrator to render an award should one party choose not to cooperate with the arbitration.
Time and money can be saved by using an alternative dispute resolution but the risks must be analyzed carefully prior to agreeing to waive your right to a civil trial. Dispute resolution rules for discovery are limited, saving time in requiring the disclosure of any applicable evidence. But this can also allow for a decision being made without all the facts being considered.
This article covers the main points of a dispute resolution but merely scratches the surface of the information available on this subject. As always, it is very important to speak to a qualified attorney when drafting or agreeing to an alternative dispute resolution provision in a lease or any other contract. (Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling office and industrial buildings, you can contact her at 310- 806-6104 or email:)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.