Skip to content

Districts limit what owners can do with property

Published:

By Shirley Bly Santa Monica

Editor: A response to your article of 4/22/02, “History repeating itself in Santa Monica.” Make no mistake, when a historical district is formed, individual property owners are giving up their property rights. They add yet another layer of control to their properties. The district member will be forced to submit plans and drawings to a committee of his/her neighbors when they want to change the exterior paint color, add a window or remove a tree or simply add air conditioning. Any exterior alterations go first to the group of neighbors, and then to landmarks commissioners. The district contributors must meet a set of “guidelines” as interpreted by the neighbors first. All of these torturous meetings do not waive the requirements of planning, building and safety, traffic, arbolist and any other department required in remodeling.

I speak with knowledge. I live in the Third Street District. I am appealing the landmark’s decision against my proposed two-car garage to the city council. The only reason for this long and costly process is because I am in the Third Street Historical District. My garage would be approved if not for my being in the Third Street District, that’s a quote from the planning department on 10/18/2001. The additional cost involved applying to the local neighbors and then the landmarks commission has been enormous, including hiring of experts, retaining an attorney, not to mention the plan re-draws and lots and lots of my time. The appeal process will add additional thousands to the final cost.

If you feel your home should be preserved, request landmark commissioners to designate it as a landmark. Districts are not about preservation of unique properties but control of property by a few active neighbors. NO MORE DISTRICTS. It’s a taking of property rights and an addition of more controls by neighbors and government.

The Third Street District has forced out a large number of renters and returned the houses to single family status resulting in many less occupants. And it’s stopped one condo building. My neighbors call it “preservation” and “protection.” As I see it, it’s the “I’ve got mine” elitist point of view. My generation questioned authority. The supporters of the district embrace it.

If our block were not a district, we would still be a place where people walk their dogs and play with their kids in the front yard, by the very nature of our wonderful Ocean Park community. Its proximity to the beach, Main Street, its modest hill and wonderful air make our community unique. We don’t need a district to help us enjoy the outdoors... and we are not a museum.

Not everyone in the Third Street Historic District is happy with the yoke of control referred to as preservation. I am not alone in my dislike of the district. We were told we could modify our homes in 1990 when they pushed through the district. That has proved to be a false hood in my experience. I’ve lived in my home for over 15 years. If there were any one thing I could change, it would be removal from the Third Street Historical District.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 30, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe