By CAROLE ORLIN
I recently watched a rerun of the 1993 movie “Mrs. Doubtfire.” Despite the movie’s billing as a comedy, the underlying premise was so sad that I found it difficult to enjoy the funny scenes.
Although there was never a question about Robin Williams’ character being a loving and involved father, he was considered too immature, disorganized and not responsible enough as a wage earner to be able to see his children on an unsupervised basis. His desperation to be with his kids drove him to take on the persona of Mrs. Doubtfire. I don’t think I’m the only person who cried through this movie.
Over the years, I have seen the negative effects of divorce, not only on the kids and mothers, but on the much-forgotten fathers. I have seen the pain suffered by these fathers as their roles in their children’s lives became increasingly diminished. I want to be very clear here: I know there are many fathers who choose not to be involved in their children’s lives. That is for another column. I am talking here about the divorced fathers who want very much to be an integral part of their children’s lives, but are relegated to visits every other weekend and Wednesdays for dinner. These are the fathers who helplessly watch as their children become virtual strangers to them — the fathers who have almost no input into their children’s lives.
These fathers have to fight with the schools to get copies of their children’s report cards and schedules of activities, and have to beg to have the children on an unscheduled day. I’m talking about fathers who feel they have to be Santa Claus year-round because they fear it is the only way their children will love them. When a father tries to buck the system and remain fully involved in his children’s lives, there are so many obstacles. They are often seen as doing this only to “get back” at the wife, or only wanting a larger role in their children’s lives in order to pay less child support. The custodial parents get to dangle the Sword of Damocles over the heads of the non-custodial parents, and can stop them from seeing their own kids if they do not meet the specific criteria set out at the time of separation or divorce.
I met with a man who spent all of his money and much of his own family’s savings on lawyers and child-estrangement counselors in a futile attempt to remain an important part of his children’s lives and to counteract the negative messages his children were getting from their mother. His former wife was actually ordered by the court to stop saying negative things about him for the children’s sake. It was a well intentioned but futile effort. How do you enforce that? I have known fathers who say, “The children will understand when they grow up,” not realizing that years of estrangement cannot be dispelled simply by chronological aging. I met with a woman who was estranged from her father for 20+ years until, after intensive therapy, she realized it was a combination of hardly seeing her father (weekends, etc.) and her mother’s negative feelings toward her father that had resulted in her negative feelings toward him. They are now on the tenuous path of getting to know and trust each other, but it is extremely difficult. How can you recapture 20+ years?
This is a catch-22 situation, because so many fathers actually believe the cultural stereotype that they are not the important parent in their children’s lives. Sadly, too many men have accepted the antiquated edict that they are there to provide money and little else. They feel powerless — and in most instances are powerless — to change things. Our court system too often reflects these beliefs. In Australia, a proposal is being discussed that emphasizes shared parenting, which would give fathers a role from the start of a separation. This hopefully could lead to “a family law guideline encouraging both parents to stay ‘meaningfully involved’ with their children” and to make joint agreements on education, where they live, etc. We might have a lot to learn from our friends “down under.”
There is an undeniably unique bond between mother and child. Nobody questions the importance of the maternal bond. However, the father-child bond, though different, is equally important. Dads, you are critically important. For the boys, you are their main role model; they can talk to you “man to man” about things that they cannot talk about with mom. They get their image of what a man is like from you. When a male child grows up in a single-parent household without a father, how does he see himself when it is time for him to be a father? Will he be less involved? Will he not realize how important his contributions to his children’s welfare can be?
For the girls, you are the first male to love them unconditionally. If you are not in their lives, whether it is your choice or not, they will experience their first rejection by a male, which needless to say can set a negative precedent. The lucky children who have the love and attention of two parents, whether divorced or married, grow up feeling more secure, more successful, more optimistic and more willing to take healthy risks. Who doesn’t do better with two lifeguards on duty?
In researching this article, I found many books on the subject and many men’s organizations and support groups. There are even attorneys that deal exclusively with fathers’ rights. Dads, do not let anyone sell you short. Whether you are just starting the painful, confusing journey of separation or divorce, or have been divorced for a long time, make an assessment of how you truly want to participate in your children’s lives. Be prepared to implement a workable strategy that moves you toward your ultimate goal of participation. If you do not succeed on one front (such as the court process), have the patience and persistence to be aggressive with the schools — ensure that you get copies of reports cards, back-to-school nights, teacher conferences, activity schedules. Do the research. Read the books. Join the organizations. And good luck in reclaiming your rightful place in your children’s lives. You and your children deserve it. (Carole).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 3, 2005. Read the original PDF.