Skip to content

Do some research, Silverstein

Published:

By Moishe K. Poyer

Regarding Ed Silverstein’s column (SMDP, Sept. 22, page 4). That particular episode of “Da Ali G Show” has been much discussed, especially by the Jewish Anti-Defamation league. It turns out Sasha Cohen sang about 12 verses, each getting more and more outlandish, with the audience joining in on the fun the more outrageous the lyrics became. By the 10th verse: “throw the Jew down the well,” the audience would have repeated anything, including, throw Ed Silverstein down the well. When they put the show together, it was edited to appear as if the verses were right on top of each other.

I guess my point is this. If you want to write a column attacking the perceived anti-semitism of George Bush, Mel Gibson and Rush Limbaugh, just do it. With a little research, Mr. Silverstein would have discovered a cobbled-together television bit was the wrong analogy to use.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 24, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe