Skip to content

Does Arnold trust the people?

Published:

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY BENNET G. KELLEY

“Ignore the politics. And trust the people” was certainly the best sound byte from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger’s State of the State Address earlier this month and a fitting line from a governor swept into office by a populist revolt. Unfortunately, it is a line well delivered but rarely honored by the governor, who repeatedly has sought to circumvent the will of the people and their representatives.

The governor’s budget proposal is a perfect illustration, as it simply ignores the requirements of Propositions 42, 57 and 98, all duly enacted by the people. The biggest controversy concerns Prop. 98, which guarantees funding levels for K-14 education. Despite a campaign pledge to balance the budget without cutting education, the governor brokered a deal with educators to reduce funding in 2004 in exchange for the promise of returning to Prop. 98 levels in 2005. The governor’s 2005 budget, however, breaks this pledge as well by providing $2.2 billion less than required under Prop. 98.

What is most amazing is that the governor ignores his own Prop. 57, which passed only nine months ago and enabled the state to borrow $15 billion to pay down its deficit. Prop. 57 funds are now being used to address a deficit in political courage by diverting $1.7 billion to help plug the gaps in the governor’s budget.

Similarly Prop. 42, approved in 2002 by nearly 70 percent of voters, requires that state gas taxes be used for transportation purposes in order to reduce traffic congestion. It appears that the governor only trusts the 30 percent who voted “no” on Prop. 42 because his budget diverts $1.3 billion from this fund as well.

More troubling has been the governor’s attempt to shift power from the Legislature to the governor. The California Constitution establishes the Legislature as the voice of the people with the authority to pass laws without the approval of the governor or by overriding a veto. In contrast, the governor may not enact any measures without legislative approval.

Schwarzenegger’s recent proposals seek to reverse this Constitutional structure to weaken the “voice of the people” and allow him to act without legislative approval. This includes enabling him to enact governmental reorganization measures unless rejected by a two-thirds vote of the Legislature, i.e., only one-third’s vote would be required to pass.

The governor’s reorganization plan calls for the elimination of 88 boards and commissions. While promoted as a cost-cutting measure, most of the changes would yield little or no savings. Instead, the changes would eliminate open meetings and public participation and give Schwarzenegger complete control over the regulation of most of the state’s professions. While Schwarzenegger often talks about taking on “special interests,” Julianne D’Angelo Fellmeth of the Center for Public Interest Law explains that these “ill-advised” changes protect special interests by removing the “only interest in Sacramento who’s not a special interest... the public interest.”

In addition, despite pledging to veto any bills that did not get a full public debate, Schwarzenegger has repeatedly overwhelmed the Legislature by introducing sweeping measures with short deadlines. Now, in another attempt to shift power from the Legislature, the governor wants to enact automatic spending cuts if the budget has not been adopted by a set date.

These are challenging times for California requiring difficult choices. It also is true that a governor with Schwarzenegger’s popularity has enormous potential to implement needed reforms. Yet Schwarzenegger should well know that, if unchecked, a leader with such popularity also can do enormous harm.

It would be a great tragedy if the populist movement that swept Schwarzenegger into office only served to make Sacramento less responsive to the people. Schwarzenegger would be wise to reverse this course by emulating Jefferson more and Conan less. If not, he might, like his predecessor, quickly discover how loud and clear the voice of the people can be. (Bennet Kelley is a Santa Monica resident, and was the co-founder and former national co-chair of the Democratic National Committee’s Saxophone Club).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 24, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe