By GUEST COMMENTARY BY MARK GOLD AND JOEL REYNOLDS
Santa Monica is considering a proposal to allow dogs to run off-leash on the beach, day or night, near Arizona Avenue. Because dogs are a source of fecal bacteria and pathogens, this proposal will undermine years of effort to clean up our beaches, protect our coastal water quality, and protect the health of beach-goers, including young children.
Even with the best of intentions, cleaning up all dog waste and urine is impossible. Inevitably, dog waste below the high tide line will pollute the local beach, putting children and swimmers at an unnecessary risk of illness. Today, Santa Monica Bay beaches often do not meet state water quality standards for recreational water contact. In fact, as a result of litigation from Heal the Bay, the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), and the Santa Monica Baykeeper, the state requires that all Santa Monica Bay beaches meet water quality standards from April to October for fecal bacteria by 2006. Public health standards must be met year round for the dry season by 2009. Already, the proposed dog beach at Arizona Avenue is among the many Santa Monica beaches that must dramatically improve water quality to comply with water quality standards to protect public health.
In 1995, USC, Heal the Bay, the Santa Monica Bay Restoration Project, the city of Los Angeles and Orange County completed a groundbreaking epidemiology study demonstrating that people who swim at bay beaches with high fecal bacteria densities are far more likely to come down with stomach flu and upper respiratory illness. Sources of fecal bacteria include polluted runoff, human sewage, cats, birds and dogs. As numerous recent studies and outbreaks have demonstrated (cryptosporidium in Milwaukee, the fecal bacteria — E. coli in numerous cases, SARS, etc.) cross species infectivity is becoming a growing cause of concern. As an example, dog waste can be a source of reoviruses, a frequent cause of stomach flu, and dog urine can harbor pathogenic microbes at low densities.
The State Department of Parks and Recreation, the Los Angeles County Department of Beaches and Harbors, and the LA County Lifeguards are already on record in opposition to opening the beach up to unleashed dogs, and we agree. Heal the Bay and NRDC have spent years seeking to strengthen and enforce sewage and stormwater requirements, as well as promote public access to our beaches. The introduction of hundreds or thousands of dogs to our beaches would run directly counter to the progress that has been made.
Santa Monica has no greater economic or environmental resource than its coastal beaches, and they must be protected. Adding a known source of fecal bacteria and pathogens to beaches that already fail to meet minimum state water quality standards is unwise, counter-productive and almost certainly illegal. Our city has an obligation to protect the health of the countless swimmers that utilize that stretch of Santa Monica beach each year.
Construction of the Santa Monica Urban Runoff Reuse Facility, authoring the tough-est stormwater ordinance in California, and most recently, completing a new and progressive urban watershed management plan that maximizes runoff retention and reuse — each of these initiatives has improved the quality of our coastal waters. To continue its leadership in cleaning up Santa Monica Bay, we strongly urge the City Council to maintain the prohibition against dogs on our beaches. (Mark Gold is the executive director of Heal the Bay and the owner of two dogs. Joel Reynolds is a senior attorney at the Natural Resources Defense Council.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 10, 2005. Read the original PDF.