By Pam Vavra Santa Monica
I attended Tuesday’s (6/25) meeting at Franklin School to better understand why some homeowners are so worked up against the Landmarks Commission. I listened intently to first-hand accounts from victims of a flawed landmark review and designation process — one that applies to anyone seeking a demolition permit for a structure that is more than 40 years old. In contrast to the hysterical alarmist rhetoric contained in promotional fliers, at the meeting I heard some legitimate complaints. So, I asked around, and am happy to report that many of the problems cited have already been fixed with modest administrative changes.
For example, one owner complained of inadequate notification (of the hearing regarding landmark status of his home). Staff acknowledged the problem and fixed it. Now, announcements are much clearer and have complete information. Another owner complained that he had obtained a demolition permit, but because it had expired, he needed to re-apply. When it came before the Landmarks Commission, they had no idea of the previous action. Again, staff acknowledged the problem and fixed it. They now provide commissioners with a form that lists all previous actions taken with regard to the property in question. Unfortunately, this owner was further delayed because staff unintentionally neglected to tell him that the state required an environmental assessment. They have since modified their procedures to reduce the likelihood of such an oversight in the future.
A more basic concern expressed at the meeting was that the landmark ordinance does not compel commissioners to weigh heavily the desire or concerns of the owner when considering a designation, even if they do so in practice. Most likely, since this is consistent with the intent of the ordinance, a text amendment could fix it, and is not difficult to achieve. Perhaps the most troublesome aspect of landmark designation has to do with incentives, especially for homes that may be historically significant, but are substantially deteriorated. The most vocal spokesman of the evening complained that his “structure of merit” suffered crumbling foundation, termite damage, and needed general maintenance and repairs. Myself, having previously restored a 110-year old Victorian home in Michigan, I know that federal funding was at one time available to help with some of these types of things; and, while no one comes unsolicited to your door with the cash in hand, I obtained confirmation that such aid does still exist.
Balancing private property rights and the public good always requires negotiation and compromise. If it is EVER appropriate for the public to intercede in order to save a monument or historical treasure from destruction by its owner, then we must have some sort of landmarks ordinance. If we need to protect individual homeowners from a potentially overzealous landmarks commission, then we must build those safeguards into its language.
Since it was explained at the meeting that there is insufficient time to qualify the Voluntary Preservation measure for the November ballot, I hope both sides would consider getting together to calmly and respectfully analyze and fix any problems with the landmark ordinance and/or staff procedures, rather than going down the costly road of throwing out the baby with the bath water.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 28, 2002. Read the original PDF.