Skip to content

Don’t unleash the beach

Published:

By Ben Jacobs Save the Sand Committee

I read with interest and amazement the Daily Press’ most recent letter to the editor written by a small vocal group of activists pushing for an unfenced, off-leash dog run at Santa Monica State Beach (SMDP, May 23, page 4), which the Santa Monica City Council is considering.

In support of their position, this small vocal group pretends that they have analyzed all necessary data concerning the safety, cleanliness and costs of a dog beach. In fact, there are few, if any facts to support a dog beach in the Santa Monica Bay, and far more that caution against it.

With regard to water quality, no study has been conducted that shows pathogens in dog waste are not harmful to humans or to the Santa Monica Bay. In fact, researchers that study water quality for a living believe that the opposite is true. And with by far the greatest number of people accessing the Santa Monica Bay over other ocean waters for recreation, this is one reason why federal and state regulations related to water quality in the Santa Monica Bay are possibly the strictest in the nation.

With regard to safety, we can consider the problems reported last year at the Long Beach dog beach. Official reports from the Long Beach dog beach reported incidents of dogs chasing or aggressively approaching people, dogs causing injuries to cyclists, and dogs attacking other dogs. Other significant problems included dogs outside of the designated dog beach area and more than one dog per owner.

With regard to costs, we again can consider the problems reported last year at the Long Beach dog beach. Long Beach officials envisioned volunteer participation in managing the dog beach, but found this did not occur. The officials recommended enlisting animal control, marine patrol, lifeguards, and park rangers to assist in the management. Are taxpayers in Santa Monica prepared to fund government agencies to supervise the Santa Monica dog beach once volunteer management fails?

An additional problem with locating an unfenced, off-leash dog beach in Santa Monica is that the area is adjacent to an area designated by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service as a critical habitat for a threatened species of bird, the snowy plover, which migrates to the beach in winter months — October through April. The dog activists concede the published studies that show the non-native dog on the beach disrupts the nesting of this native species, but adopt a “let them eat cake” attitude toward the tiny bird. They justify the introduction of a dog beach on the basis that less than two dozen snowy plovers have been sighted in Santa Monica.

The activists also state that the area for the proposed off-leash dog beach is approximately a half mile from the area where snowy plovers have been sighted. This might make some sense if the dog beach were fenced or if studies reported that the snowy plover, finishing its southern migration, would be able to recognize lifeguard tower 11 from lifeguard tower 12 and know to stay north of tower 12. However, neither of these assumptions are reality. We also have official reports from Long Beach that found a significant problem at the dog beach was dogs outside the designated area. It doesn’t strain the imagination to envision dogs outside the Santa Monica dog beach area chasing snowy plovers.

The bottom line is that Santa Monica, along with a few other beach areas like Dockweiler and Hermosa, are the few beach areas in the Santa Monica Bay designated as critical habitat for the snowy plovers. There are many other beach areas in the Santa Monica Bay, including Manhattan, Redondo, and Torrance, that are not critical habitats. Doesn’t it make more sense for the dog activists to introduce the notion of an unfenced dog beach at one of those beaches?

We urge all citizens to join with Heal the Bay, Save the Sand, the Audubon Society, the State Department of Parks, the Los Angeles County Department of Beaches and Harbors, the LA County Lifeguards, the Natural Resources Defense Council and urge your elected officials to prevent this potentially disastrous plan.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 27, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe