Skip to content

Doubletree gathering was a protest, not a celebration

Published:

By Chuck Allord Santa Monica

Editor:

Oscar de la Torre made some erroneous statements in his opinion piece “Samohi rally celebrated Caesar Chavez, nothing more” (Santa Monica Daily Press, Thursday, April 18, 2002.)

Mr. De la Torre claims that the event was to “celebrate the vision and values of Cesar E. Chavez.” On the contrary, why did the organizers and Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees (HERE), Local 814 send out a press release inviting all the press to join them and students of Samohi in a labor rally against the Doubletree Hotel? And, why were printed “Doubletree is Non-Union” HERE, Local 814 picket signs handed out to rally participants on campus to march with?

As someone who was there with my own picket sign protesting the school district selling out to HERE Local 814, I observed that the rally was led by Kurt Peterson, head of HERE, Local 814. Everyone was chanting “se se puede” and yelling about the union and “rights for Doubletree workers” as they marched. Not one word was uttered about Cesar E. Chavez.

Mr. De La Torre says, Ms. Dolores Huerta, co-founder of the United Farm Workers an invited speaker, told the students about “the values of nonviolence, compassion, unity, etc.” Yet, is was Ms. Huerta who said to the assembly in front of the hotel that “she had been arrested 21 or 22 times and one more arrest wouldn’t make a difference.” This is advocating nonviolent protest and compassion?

Mr. de la Torre says the rally provided the opportunity for participants to “practice their first amendment rights in a peaceful demonstration” yet he fails to disclose that there were three “confrontations” with the police who were on scene. The first was when the marchers were met on the hotel driveway in front of the hotel on Fourth Street. Peterson, stopped the march and led chants against the Double Tree hotel and at the police who were protecting the front of hotel.

The marchers then proceeded around to the Olympic Boulevard side of the hotel. There, some of the marchers spotted more police in the hotel parking lot and stopped to taunt, and hurl threats and vulgarities at the officers assembled.

Mr. De La Torre says that the safety of the participants “was guaranteed” however, apparently Mr. de la Torre, school district superintendent, John Deasy, or anyone else participating in this rally considered what might have happened if a group of counter demonstrators, had showed up and challenged the marchers or if some hotheaded participant decided to follow Delores Huerte’s suggestion to “get arrested.” de La Torre takes issue with letter to the editor writer, Richard Firth, who commented correctly when he wrote “there was a potential for violent conflict.” This is why the police are deployed in a “worst case scenario” mode for all labor rallies — including previous HERE, Local 814 Loew’s Hotel demonstrations in the past.

I would hate to think what would have happened if the police were not present to keep order and Mr. Peterson either seized the opportunity to enter the hotel or otherwise lost control of the situation due to immature and emotional teenagers taking it upon themselves to do the same after already being fired up.

Mr. de la Torre says that somehow police protection of private property — which is standard procedure for all rallies of this type — is “sending a message we don’t trust our youth.”

Mr. de la Torre should go back and retake high school Civics 101. When he helped organize a rally supporting unionization of the Doubletree hotel, did he consider the rights and dignity of the workers who don’t want a union?

Does he respect the rights of the hotel management, owners or the thousands of mom and pop stockholders who have invested in Hilton, the owner of the Doubletree? Obviously not. This is all really designed to deflect the controversy concerning the use of school property and our kids for propaganda purposes by an off-campus organization by tossing it back to blaming the police. Sorry, Oscar, we're too smart for that.

If this were a rally sponsored by hotel owners, would de la Torre speak so compassionately about “dignity, respect, and threat to justice?” I think not. With the union sympathizers, there is only one way and it’s “my way.” That is the real lesson our students were taught.

There was no open debate on the issue. In fact, Mr. de la Torre and HERE representatives don’t want you or our students to know the whole story. They rather propagandize and manipulate the facts. Bringing in the race card and the social class element into the mix is unfair, exploitive and the cheapest of shots.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 22, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe