The day laborer situation on 11th Street, much to the chagrin of nearby residents and business owners, appears to be falling on deaf ears at City Hall. For years, hundreds of migrants have lined the street between Broadway and Olympic Avenue on a daily basis, hoping for under-the-table pay in exchange for manual labor.
Residents have been complaining all the while that their neighborhood has become blighted with trash, debris, loitering, and individuals urinating and defecating on the sidewalks and adjacent alleys.
Whether or not you agree with allowing migrants to accept pay without paying taxes, the issue is a quality-of-life one here in Santa Monica. In August, about a dozen residents waited for hours to speak to the City Council, looking for solutions to the problem. They were put off by the council, who said staff would investigate the situation. Some of those same residents returned this week, asking what’s been done. There was no response from the City Council. However, city staff has suggested that portable toilets may be the solution.
But there’s a problem. That’s what they said two years ago and nothing was ever done — not that toilets are going to solve Santa Monica’s day laborer problem anyway. One councilmember has even suggested that he doesn’t think it’s an issue, since he hasn’t heard that many complaints from that many people.
One only has to take a drive down 11th Street to know it’s a problem — just the sight of trash strewn all over the corridor is bad enough for Santa Monica standards. But try taking a stroll down the street, with the smell of urine permeating the air. Would this be acceptable in any of the councilmembers’ neighborhoods — Sunset Park, north of Montana, or north of Wilshire — where they all reside?
Pasadena had a similar problem and it solved it by passing a law that prohibits vehicles from stopping in posted areas where day laborers used to congregate, as well as beefing up enforcement of existing laws. The city also allowed a non-profit to set up shop in Pasadena which serves as an organized way for day laborers to find work.
If communities like Pasadena can figure it out, Santa Monica should be able to as well. It shouldn’t take an act from City Council to put in toilets, or enforce general municipal codes like loitering, littering and soliciting. For as progressive and cutting edge on labor-related issues as Santa Monica is, it’s surprising the local government hasn’t made strides in finding work for these people in an organized fashion.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 30, 2005. Read the original PDF.