Skip to content

Election ’04: Restoring

Published:

democracy at work

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOHN LOGAN

After the debacle over hanging chads in Florida and more recent concerns about computer voting and purged voter lists, many Americans are concerned about ensuring a fair election in November. Yet, in one important arena, we routinely tolerate elections that are neither free nor fair: union certification elections.

Sixty-nine years ago President Roosevelt signed into law the National Labor Relations Act. Originally designed to protect workers’ right to choose a union, the NLRA election system has been transformed into a powerful tool for maintaining a union-free environment.

If the 2004 presidential election were run according to the rules that operate in union certification elections, it would look something like this: ■ Bush has unlimited television time throughout the campaign, including several hours a day of compulsory viewing. Kerry is restricted to door-to-door campaigning, and when he does so, Bush accuses him of violating voters’ privacy. ■ Bush spends several thousand dollars per voter to convince the electorate to reject Kerry. He outspends his opponent by millions of dollars (no stretch there). ■ Bush hires consultants who specialize in intimidating voters. These “experts” make Karl Rove look like a novice. Some consultants even offer Bush a “money back guarantee” that he will win the election. ■ Bush is required to report how much he spends only if his consultants make direct contact with voters. If they restrict their activities to preparing campaign materials, training Bush officials in anti-Kerry tactics and directing overall campaign strategy, the consultants are not required to disclose their fees. ■ Bush officials threaten outspoken Kerry supporters, and sack a few to send a stark message to the others. Bush officials caught threatening Kerry supporters face the maximum penalty of having to sign a letter promising not to do it again. ■ Bush delays the election by several months by claiming that many Kerry supporters are ineligible to vote. This allows him more time to conduct his aggressive campaign and prevents some Kerry supporters from voting. ■ Bush officials warn voters that a Kerry victory will devastate the economy and result in the off-shoring of their jobs. To reinforce this point, Bush officials distribute literature stating that previous Kerry victories were followed by job losses and economic devastation. ■ Bush’s consultants encourage voters to exhibit their anti-Kerry sentiments through T-shirts, buttons, balloons and other campaign materials. Voters who attempt to display their support for Kerry are threatened with dismissal and relocated to minimize their contact with undecided voters. ■ Voting takes place at Republican campaign offices in the presence of senior Bush officials. As they prepare to cast their ballots, voters see Bush officials planning a post-election “victory party.” ■ After Kerry wins, Bush contests the result of the election. The courts take several years to rule on Bush’s frivolous complaints. Bush remains in office while the courts deliberate and continues to intimidate Kerry supporters. ■ After the courts declare Kerry the winner, Bush’s consultants teach him how to obstruct every one of Kerry’s policies. Bush continues to target Kerry supporters, hoping to demoralize them. After several years of persistent aggression, Kerry gives up.

If you substitute the employer for Bush, the union for Kerry, and employees for voters, you get a pretty accurate description of how union certification elections operate. In one respect, however, the comparison between union elections and the presidential election is fundamentally inappropriate; unlike political elections, the union certification process was never intended to be a contest between two equal parties. Rather, the intention of the NLRA was to provide an objective and neutral means of verifying whether a majority of employees wanted independent representation. Employer interference with the verification process is analogous to Bush spending millions of dollars to secure the re-election of Silvio Berlusconi or Tony Blair.

Today, employers rarely remain neutral when their employees attempt to form a union. The industry of anti-union consultants and law firms devoted to undermining employees’ right to choose a union is worth hundreds of millions of dollars per year. One consultant firm offers employers a “money back guarantee” in the event of a union election victory. One can imagine the justifiable outrage if consultants offered employers a money back guarantee that their employees would be unable to exercise their rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act — yet this happens every day with the right to choose a union. All available evidence suggests that there are more than 40 million Americans who would like union representation, but who can’t get it under the existing NLRA system. For these employees, union certification elections are sham elections without democracy. We would not tolerate such an unjust system in political elections, nor should we tolerate it in workplace elections. (John Logan teaches industrial relations at the London School of Economics. His publications have appeared in leading academic journals in the United States, UK and Canada).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 23, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe