By THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Over the past few weeks, President Bush has been working with his staff to accept the resignations of several cabinet members, to reshuffle his appointees, and to vet possible new nominees. Bush is trying to reassemble a cabinet willing to take on his ambitious second-term agenda, which he has said will include Social Security reform, permanent tax reform, fighting the war on terrorism, and continuing to combat the insurgents and assist with nation-building in Iraq and Afghanistan.
According to a recent news report, there are still at least “a half a dozen more resignations” on the way. This would bring the total number of cabinet resignations during Bush’s presidency up to about 15 (seven since the election, two prior to the election and six more still to come). While this may seem like a large number, it’s not unusual for a two-term president to have significant turnover in his cabinet.
A LexisNexis database study showed that President Ronald Reagan had only one cabinet member — other than the vice president — who served all eight years. Many left under a cloud of suspicion after the Iran-Contra hearings, but nevertheless, turnover in cabinet positions is fairly common. Clinton had six resignations after his first term. Overall, Clinton lost 10 of his original cabinet members, and he had to replace several of their replacements, naming four secretaries of commerce, and three secretaries of treasury, energy and defense during his tenure.
President Bush has named four replacements thus far: Dr. Rice for state; Ms. Spellings for education; Mr. Gut-ierrez for commerce; and Mr. Gonzales for Attorney General. Most expect him to announce others in the coming weeks, and the administration has said that it’s working on having all of their new cabinet members on a path towards confirmation by the first of the year.
While Bush is moving slightly more rapidly than some previous administrations on new nominations, there is nothing overly surprising about the way they are conducting themselves. The president and his team are working deliberately and quietly to fill the vacancies, and get moving on their second term because they are well aware that with each day that passes their honeymoon period grows shorter and their lame duck status looms larger.
All outward appearances then would suggest that every move the administration is making is no more significant than what every other president has done during their time in office. While this is true, it’s also possible to uncover clues about Bush’s unique leadership style by the company he desires to keep.
Here’s The Thing... While there is still great uncertainty about all of the new heads of departments, it’s clear by the choices that Bush has made that he wants one thing from his new cabinet — a hall of mirrors.
Despite appearances, Bush is not looking for diversity. He may have named two women, one African-American, and two Hispanics, but in terms of ideology, these four picks all share his outlook on the world. These individuals are all people he has either known for a long time, and are extremely loyal to him and his family, or are reputed to be in “lock step” with his ideas.
Make no mistake: Bush wants his policies reflected back to him. He wants validation. He does not want any level of questioning. This is not Clinton or FDR’s “bull pen.” This is not even the “big tent” the Republican Party often proudly boasts of hoisting over such moderates as our own Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Welcome to Bush’s second term. He is on a mission to accomplish as much as he can with as little friction, division and discussion as possible. Expect his cabinet meetings to be short and devoid of original ideas. Expect his administration to have even more message discipline than the first. Expect his presidency to be focused like a laser beam on legislative accomplishments in the same way it was focused on reelection during the first.
The only question that remains for us observers is how much will he actually be able to do? Will the checks and balances built into our system fray the Republican unity? Time will tell and the clock is ticking. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 2, 2004. Read the original PDF.