By Derek Loughran Santa Monica
Michael Berliner’s guest commentary titled, “If environmentalism succeeds, it will make human life impossible,” (SMDP, April 19, page 4) is astounding in its willful ignorance. Berliner paints the entire environmentalist movement with one broad brush as haters of humanity and implies all who care about clean water, clean air, preventing deforestation, and the slaughter of endangered species are “a grave danger to mankind.” On the contrary, the arrogant philosophy that man has the right to despoil the world for profit because he is at the top of the food chain is the real “grave danger.” Challenging businesses and governments that destroy human health and the environment, and holding them responsible for their actions, is a positive goal that helps all humanity.
Environmentalists work for the preservation of nature and the human race, not against it. One example — and I could list dozens — not a year goes by without news reports of scientists finding possible cures for life threatening diseases in a rare jungle plant. Therefore, preventing the wholesale clear cutting of rainforests is an attempt to help mankind. The Brazilian and African rainforests are also the “lungs of the earth” and supply a large part of the world’s oxygen. Then again, maybe Mr. Berliner doesn’t care what he breathes.
Whether he can admit it or not, Berliner has personally benefited from the work of environmentalists in many ways. His tap water is monitored for heavy metals, bacteria and other chemicals so he isn’t poisoned. The gas he puts in his SUV (I bet he drives a really big one because it’s his right as an individualist) has been reformulated to produce less toxic emissions. Does he think the DWP and the oil companies do that just to be nice? Environmentalists helped compel the government to mandate cleaner water, lower fuel consumption through the CAFE standards, and make the gas burn cleaner. Hardly a threat to mankind.
Extremists exist in any movement and, unfortunately, the media swarms to spotlight the sensational acts of a few, such as torching SUVs. Most environmentalists, which include biologists, physicians, ecologists, chemists, urban planners, and wind and solar power engineers, do want a “balance” between the needs of man and the need to protect the environment. Without the environmental movement, we might have had many more catastrophic events such as Chernobyl, Three Mile Island, and the Exxon Valdez. Three disasters due primarily to placing profit above protection of humanity and our natural resources.
Michael Berliner’s assertion that environmentalism is “hatred of science” is a myopic, biased, cynical view filtered through the prism of his extremist personal ideology.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 22, 2004. Read the original PDF.