Skip to content

Family should take responsibility

Published:

It never ceases to amaze me how many articles I read about families that come here seeking the “American Dream” and yet do everything to make sure it DOESN’T happen for them! (RE: 1/24/03) The “landlord verses poor, low-income tenant” article featuring the Vivanco family is pathetic. Not because Liska is allegedly an evil landlord, but because Mr. and Mrs. V were privileged enough come to this country, were lucky enough to get a rent-controlled apartment and they still have not one but two children!

When will these people get it? If you are poor and you come here with no marketable skills and you don’t speak the language, then you are still going to be poor! (Yes, it’s a hell of a lot better to be poor in America where you can get a rent-controlled apartment well under market value, but you are still poor!) Why would you add to your financial burden by having children? WHY?!?

It doesn’t take a Ph.D to figure out that if you can’t feed, clothe and shelter yourself, then you certainly can’t feed, clothe and shelter yourself AND children!

The Vivancos had a chance back in 1987 when they were paying $416 for a 2-bedroom apartment to begin down the road to obtaining the “dream.”

Based on government stats, no more than 30 percent of your income should go to housing. That would mean their combined salaries should have been $16.5K per year (not hard to do for two people even if they were making minimum wage at the time). In today’s dollars, they would have to be earning 25K with their $623 monthly rent (again, not hard to do with two incomes).

So what happened? They have little Ernesto. All right, maybe things were looking up for Mr. and Mrs. V. Maybe Candido got a big raise that year and decided, “Hey, let’s have a kid.” But wait a minute — who’s going to care for the baby? Answer — Mrs. V. So now they are down to one income. An income that cannot possibly keep them on the road to the “dream.” Then seven years later — little Teresa shows up. Now we have a family of four living in a two-bedroom apartment with NO chance of “movin’ on up.”

Mr. and Mrs. V made some very path-altering decisions back in 1986 and 1993. Had they not decided to have children and simply continued to progress in their jobs, they would be making $32,000 per year (assuming a worst case scenario of a modest 4 percent raise per year and no job advancement). That would mean that in today’s dollars they would only be paying 23 percent of their income towards rent. Hell, maybe they wouldn’t have needed a two-bedroom in the first place! Maybe they could have saved enough money to buy a place of their own instead of living in a rent-controlled apartment for their entire lives!

Mrs. V said, “We came to find our American dream … that dream has become a nightmare ever since we received the notice.” I would argue that the nightmare began when she and her husband over-extended themselves by having children they could not afford. And now we’re supposed to feel sorry for them? Two words: Personal responsibility. (By the way, the allegation from Dr. Hopper that Mr. V’s affliction “was brought on by” the stress of the eviction proceedings is total BS. The Wolf-Parkinson-White Syndrome is a unique condition present from birth. In patients with WPWS, an extra conduction channel or “cable” connects the upper chambers to the lower chambers of the heart.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 27, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe