Skip to content

Favoring unleashed dog recreation over a threatened species

Published:

By Tom Babbitt Santa Monica

Small vocal groups are pushing for unleashed, unfenced dog beaches in Santa Monica and Dockweiler (in El Segundo). Both of these locations include areas designated by the U.S. government as protected for the snowy plover, a small bird that nests on the sands of certain west coast beaches. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service classifies the bird as “threatened,” and the California Department of Fish and Game classifies the bird as a “species of special concern.” The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service found the presence of dogs on beaches, particularly unleashed dogs, to be a “serious threat to snowy plovers during both the breeding and nonbreeding seasons” because dogs chase snowy plovers and destroy nests. While most breeds of dogs are natural predators, even when not deliberately chasing snowy plovers, the mere presence of dogs on the beach tended to flush the birds from their nests and interrupt roosting and feeding. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service did not find the same level of flushing by the presence of humans on the beach.

One vocal group believes dogs can co-exist with the snowy plover because dog owners will just keep their dogs away from the birds and their nests. Keeping these animals separated would be a remarkable accomplishment given the unleashed, unfenced nature of the dog beach this group desires. In fact, reports at two northern California beaches that provided symbolic fencing for nesting by the snowy plover reported dogs destroying eggs inside the symbolic fencing.

Beaches like Santa Monica and Dockweiler are the natural habitat for the snowy plover. Beaches are not the natural habitat of dogs. The snowy plover is in danger of extinction. Common sense dictates that an unleashed dog beach not be anywhere near the nesting area of the snowy plover, much less include the area. This is possible. There are many other beach areas in Los Angeles County that have not been designated protected areas for the snowy plover. Please consider the merits of favoring an unleashed dog beach over a threatened species and express your views with your elected officials.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 16, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe