By THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Debate talk hasn’t stopped since before last Tuesday, and you can bet it won’t cease until next Thursday, after the final presidential debate in Arizona.
Very little time is spent on the debates themselves. This year, the presidential candidates will share the spotlight for under five hours, while the vice presidential candidates dueled for only 90 minutes. Yet the chattering class will have spent most of the other 354 hours of the 360 hours in this 15-day time span explaining to the American people (a) what to expect to see; (b) what we saw; (c) whether it was good or bad and (d) who did better or worse.
In each debate, the candidates made cogent points about the substantive issues that face our nation, but what was more interesting to me were how the stories about what they said moved through the media and how the public perception about the debates seemed to change over time. It’s like one giant game of “operator,” where you whisper in the ear of a friend some message, and they pass it along to the next person in the row, and by the time it reaches the last person, the original message is completely distorted.
To a certain extent this has always happened in politics, but between televised debate-watch focus groups, online unscientific polls, instant-response statistically significant polls, web-logging (blogging), and the 24-hour cable news networks, the feedback loops have never been so vigorous. Within minutes of the debate, winners and losers are declared, but more importantly, over time these perceptions snowball. They take on a momentum of their own.
In the presidential debate last Thursday, it was widely thought that Sen. John Kerry did better than President Bush. Most instant polls — the scientific ones with the random samples — tended to have Kerry leading between eight to 12 points, about 47 percent to 38 percent. The ABC News, CBS News, and Gallup Organizations all showed a clear, but not an overwhelming victory for Kerry.
By Monday, you would have thought that Kerry had scored a knockout punch. Not only were the pundits talking about how Kerry had beat up on Bush, but they were also saying that Kerry was on an upswing. Several of the follow-up polls released on Sunday and Monday showed that people believed that Kerry had won the debate on average by about 20-25 percent points, about 60 percent to 40 percent.
Kerry won both the debate and the spin. He also won the debate recall — what people remember, and what people are told happened in the debate.
The vice presidential debate couldn’t have been more different. It was brutal. The only moment of compassion came when Sen. John Edwards acknowledged Vice President Dick Cheney and his family’s love for their lesbian daughter, which served to extract all the venom from the fight. Their genuine exchange on a personally difficult issue deflated the last 20 minutes of the debate, and by the end, both candidates seemed worn down, and ready to call it a draw, which was exactly how the media portrayed it.
Most television pundits said things like, “Edwards hung in there and got in some jabs, but Cheney who is skilled in the art of debate, made a much better case for the administration than did President Bush last Thursday.”
The people saw this debate very differently. Online polls that were not scientific were hugely in Edwards favor, about 90 percent versus 5 percent for Cheney. The blogs were mostly focused on how cruel the debate was, while they were trying to assess the divergent facts that were espoused. The scientific polls had contradictory results. The ABC News poll, which had more Republicans in the sample than Democrats, said Cheney won — 43 percent to 35 percent — while the CBS News poll that did not have sample issues declared Edwards the winner — 41 percent to 28 percent.
This debate was not a tie — no harm, no foul — the way the pundits were talking about it. According to the people, this debate was lop-sided, inflammatory and partisan. Both men were sliced up.
The only reporter who seemed to capture the night’s events the way the people felt was Keith Olbermann, who kept score of the debate “question round by question round.” He noted the hits, points and misses, and like a boxing match he was able to assess a winner even through all the blood (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6133222/ #Olbermann).
HERE’S THE THING: Memory has a way of changing over time — the facts fade, yet the image becomes clearer. Whether a candidate wins or loses has more to do with expectations and recollections, than with substance or style.
Recall a winner, and you’ll make a winner, which means you can control the outcome as much as your candidate. Never lose sight of the fact that perception is reality in politics. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 7, 2004. Read the original PDF.