Skip to content

Film critic Dunn pushes the Oscar envelope

Published:

BEST PICTURE The nominees: “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King;” “Lost in Translation;” “Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World,” “Mystic River,” “Seabiscuit.”

Should win: “The Return of the King” is the exclamation point on what many consider to be the finest film trilogy of all time. The first two films were slighted in this category by the Academy, and it’s hard to imagine it happening again.

Could win: “Mystic River” or “Lost in Translation,” but highly unlikely.

Will win: “The Return of the King.”

BEST ACTOR The nominees: Johnny Depp, “Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl;” Ben Kingsley, “House of Sand and Fog;” Jude Law, “Cold Mountain;” Bill Murray, “Lost in Translation;” Sean Penn, “Mystic River.”

Should win: Penn and Murray are the favorites, but plenty of people will be rooting for Depp, the surprise winner at last week’s SAG Awards for his fantastic turn as a whacked-out buccaneer in “Pirates of the Caribbean.” Good as Johnny is, though, Murray deserves the gold statue this year.

Could win: Murray’s campaign has a lot of momentum behind it. Kingsley has had his name called before (“Ghandi,” 1983), and Oscar loves a winner. He might sneak up on the Big Three. The only sure thing in this category is that Jude Law won’t win, so lay off him in the office pools.

Will win: Penn. The questions are will he show up to accept the award, and how outrageous will his acceptance speech be?

BEST ACTRESS The nominees: Keisha Castle-Hughes, “Whale Rider;” Diane Keaton, “Something’s Gotta Give;” Samantha Morton, “In America;” Charlize Theron, “Monster;” Naomi Watts, “21 Grams.”

Should win: Great performances by all the nominees in this category, but Theron’s was transcendent.

Could win: Keaton’s been around a long time, and so have the majority of the Academy’s voters. Plus, there’s always the “Jack factor” — her co-star is an Oscar magnet, so maybe she wins by association.

Will win: Nothing impresses Hollywood more than a stunning beauty making herself look ugly for a role. Theron became a monster and for that she’ll get an Oscar.

DIRECTOR The nominees: Fernando Meirelles, “City of God;” Peter Jackson, “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King;” Sofia Coppola, “Lost in Translation;” Peter Weir, “Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World;” Clint Eastwood, “Mystic River.”

Should win: Jackson, with a nod to Meirelles.

Could win: Coppola Will win: Jackson SUPPORTING ACTOR The nominees: Alec Baldwin, “The Cooler;” Benicio Del Toro, “21 Grams;” Djimon Hounsou, “In America;” Tim Robbins, “Mystic River;” Ken Watanabe, “The Last Samurai.”

Should win: Robbins and Del Toro are both deserving nominees, though the latter should have been included in the leading man category. Baldwin, though, steals every scene in “The Cooler” and ought to be honored for it.

Could win: Anyone but Hounsou, at a disadvantage because few saw Jim Sheridan’s marvelous film.

Will win: Robbins has already nabbed a Golden Globe and SAG Award. He’ll add another trophy to his collection Sunday.

SUPPORTING ACTRESS The nominees: Shohreh Aghdashloo, “House of Sand and Fog;” Patricia Clarkson, “Pieces of April;” Marcia Gay Harden, “Mystic River;” Holly Hunter, “Thirteen;” Renée Zellweger, “Cold Mountain.”

Should win: Zellweger is the best of the bunch.

Could win: Clarkson was great in two films this year, “April” and “The Station Agent,” and the voters may have taken that into account when they filled out their ballots.

Will win: Three-time Oscar nominee Zellweger is virtually a lock.

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY The nominees: Denys Arcand, “The Barbarian Invasions;” Steven Knight, “Dirty Pretty Things;” Andrew Stanton, Bob Peterson and David Reynolds, “Finding Nemo;” Jim Sheridan, Naomi Sheridan and Kirsten Sheridan, “In America;” Sofia Coppola, “Lost in Translation.”

Should win: Tough one. There’s some truly inspired work on display. My vote, if I had one, would go to the Sheridans.

Could win: “Nemo” was a huge hit, and with so little family-friendly fare represented at the Awards, it might get the nod here.

Will win: Coppola wins this one as consolation for losing the director’s award.

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY The nominees: Robert Pulcini and Shari Springer Berman, “American Splendor;” Braulio Mantovani, “City of God;” Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and Peter Jackson, “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King;” Brian Helgeland, “Mystic River;” Gary Ross, “Seabiscuit.”

Should win: Jackson, et al. Could win: Pulcini and Berman for critic fave “Splendor,” and Mantovani.

Will win: Jackson, et al … this is “The Lord of the Rings” year.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe