Skip to content

Free your mind, the rest of the world may follow

Published:

By Beth Solomon

I was thrilled when a friend invited me to her family’s Passover seder last year in Beverly Hills. Not having been to one since I was a little girl (about 85 years ago), I could hardly wait to soak up the teachings about freedom, liberation and peace that I was sure would be at the heart of the ceremony.

Things started off well as the first prayers invoked God and blessed the wine. Hard-boiled eggs, parsley in salt water and unleavened bread symbolized various aspects of the plight of the enslaved Jews of Egypt, on the way to liberation.

But then I started to hear talk of Egyptians hating Jews, Syrians hating Jews, and others who hate. There were drops of blood symbolized in the meal. I thought, “Is it really helpful to remind our children of all the hatred that has existed in history? And by talking about all the groups who hate, aren’t we indoctrinating our children to understand the world through a vocabulary of hate, suspicion and vengeance?”

I reached for the vino. Luckily, kosher wine has come a long way.

The Passover liberation story was then applied to Iraq, which had just been visited — well, bombed — by America. Iraq’s “liberation” was compared to the American liberation of Nazi Germany.

I had two pieces of surprisingly good kosher unleavened chocolate cake and managed to keep my mouth shut.

It’s easy to see now that the “liberation” of Iraq has not been viewed as such by the Iraqis. To them, it’s enslavement.

But to what extent is the problem that we define life in these terms, and in doing so, trap ourselves in an enslavement-liberation cycle in our own minds? How often do our own past injuries govern our current behavior, enslaving us in patterns that harm us and those around us?

Consider what happened in our own country in early 2001. Newly appointed National Security Adviser Condoleeza Rice asked her staff for memorandums describing the most urgent problems facing the country. The chief counterterror-ism expert, Richard Clarke, responded with a lengthy e-mail. He called the memo (which is still classified) a thorough description of the threat posed by al- Qaeda, along with a full plan to combat its growing menace.

Rice and her deputy now say they did-n’t think much of the memo, characterizing it as a hodgepodge of ideas about how to make life miserable for Osama bin Laden.

Rice blocked Clarke from working directly with the secretaries of state and defense, as well as the CIA director — which he considered a demotion.

Clarke started to skip National Security Council staff meetings, saying he was too busy to attend. Rice didn’t take it well. According to the New York Times, she asked him to show up once. He didn’t. “We continued to have a problem,” she told the Times. “I asked him to come twice. We didn’t have a problem after that.”

Clearly, they did have a problem. And so did we. The result of their animosity — an enslavement in notions of disrespect — was a breakdown in communication that may have weakened our national security, and may well have been a key factor in the breakdown of our defenses that led to 9- 11. South African leader Nelson Mandela had a different — and more useful — concept of enslavement and liberation. He said it was during his decades alone in prison “that my hunger for the freedom of my own people became a hunger for the freedom of all people, black and white. I knew as well as I knew anything that the oppressor must be liberated just as surely as the oppressed. A man who takes away a man’s freedom is a prisoner of hatred, he is locked behind the bars of prejudice. Both are robbed of their humanity.”

Mandela wrote that we are not yet free, but that we have achieved the freedom to be free. From the Passover table, to the White House, to the mosques in Fallujah, let us liberate ourselves from hatred, and pray that our brothers and sisters world-wide can do the same. (Beth Solomon is a Left Coast writer reachable at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 7, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe