By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
The GOP and President Bush’s latest scheme to create a wedge issue to beat up Democrats — a Constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage — went down in flames when the administration could-n’t even arm twist a majority of their own.
The effort was led by the same old nasty group of ultra right-wing Republican party hijackers, such as majority leader Representative Tom DeLay and Vice President Dick Cheney — whose own wife opposes the ban. These narrow thinkers seem little different than the backward bigots who fought to keep interracial marriage illegal because — and this may sound familiar — it was a threat to the sanctity of marriage and our society. Though to be fair, at least some of the earlier breed, such as the late Sen. Strom Thurmond, did believe in civil unions with the underage daughters of their maids.
The rhetoric from these supporters of state sponsored intolerance was the usual GOP foul and offensive fare. For example, Republican Sen. Rick Santorum of Pennsylvania compared gay marriage to Al Qaeda terrorists by suggesting the amendment to ban gay marriage was true homeland security (see “aside” below). Equally appalling is the argument forwarded by David Frum, Bush’s old speechwriter, columnist Charles Krauthammer and the legions of the Republican controlled and financed echo chamber, who suggested that there is no difference between same sex relationships and polygamy, child molestation and incest.
Let me list the differences. First, it is not illegal to be gay here (though it is in most radical Muslim countries.) Second, polygamy is illegal in all 50 states. Third, child molestation is a crime in every western country. Fourth, incest is abhorred throughout the world. And finally, all these crimes are allowed to flourish, unabated, under the very noses of some of the staunchest supporters of the constitutional gay marriage ban.
Among the residents of Arizona, Colorado and, in particular, Utah, according to Jon Krakauer in his book, “Under The Banner of heaven,” are between 20,000 and 100,000 fundamentalist Mormons. This extreme sect, disavowed by the more main-stream LDS Mormon church, strictly adheres to the teachings of Mormon founder John Smith who advocated plural marriage or polygamy. In fact, the taking of multiple wives is not only allowed, but it is considered a divine obligation.
Now, one might think that these law breaking “sinners,” living in ultra conservative states such as Utah, home of two of the most vocal self-proclaimed protectors of the sanctity of marriage, Sens Orin Hatch and William Bennett, might be in hiding. Nothing could be further from the truth.
According to Krakauer, all but a handful of the 9,000 residents of Colorado City, a town on the Arizona/Utah border, are Mormon fundamentalists engaged in polygamy. And there are many such communities across Arizona, Colorado, Utah and throughout the West, Canada and Mexico. But there is even a darker side.
The majority of these plural marriages are arranged. The brides are often adolescent girls, some as young as 12, who are forced into marriages with men many times their age. One girl of 16 was forced to marry a man in his 80s. And there are cases in which mothers encouraged their daughters to marry their stepfathers.
Many of the marriages are abusive. And, if the church becomes displeased with the husband, the wives can be taken away and given, like chattel, to another man. If the women protest — which is rare since they are forbidden to watch television or have any contact with the outside world — they are threatened with eternal damnation. If that doesn’t work, “wayward wives” may be taken to a “leave no marriage behind” re-education camp where they are brutally beaten and abused. Some of these women have even been murdered.
Most of the marriages take place in spiritual ceremonies, but have no legal standing. This allows the additional wives to claim to be single mothers and tap into federal assistance. Colorado City gets a whopping $8 in federal funds for every $1 they pay in taxes, which they call “bleeding the beast.” It also allows the faithful to avoid prosecution for polygamy, though, in the case of underage brides, opens them up to charges of child rape. Incest also is rampant in these communities. And yet these Fundamentalist Mormons believe that homosexuality should be punished by death.
So what have Sens Hatch and Bennett done to stop the polygamy, incest and child rape/slavery that is going on under their watch? Nothing. What about Attorney General Ashcroft, a man so offended by sexuality that he spent thousands to cover the bare breast of a marble statue. Has he launched an investigation to put these marriage miscreants behind bars? No. Then there’s President Bush, the main thrust behind the gay marriage ban. Has he paraded around the country expressing outrage at such immoral criminal conduct? Of course not.
This amendment was never about the sanctity of marriage nor does it have anything to do with the Republicans’ feigned moral outrage. It was a political dirty trick and it failed.
More important to Bush, Mormon fundamentalists are much more likely to vote for him than gays. And the president needs every vote he can get.
ASIDE TO SENATOR SANTORUM: Having lost a family member in the World Trade Center attack, let me assure you that saying “I do,” to the person you love, regardless of sexual orientation, bears no similarity to a father of three telling the person he loves, “It doesn’t look like I’m going to make it. Tell the kids I love them.” And for you to plumb the depths of depravity by making such a cynical comparison for selfish political gain creates a far greater threat to our society than two loving people ever could. You should be ashamed. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living who splits his time between Santa Monica and Georgetown Lake, Mont. Comments and requests for copies of this column may be addressed to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 28, 2004. Read the original PDF.