Skip to content

God only knows why we still kill in his name

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

As evidenced by the above quote, Sam Harris, in his book “The End Of Faith” blames religion for the vast majority of wars and conflicts. It also is the catalyst responsible for many of history’s greatest atrocities. The crusades, pogroms, witch-hunts, the Spanish Inquisition and the Holocaust, were all religious persecutions.

But this comprehensive, compelling and thought-provoking argument against the ridiculousness and danger of organized religion — one that that might even give hard-core evangelicals pause — goes much further.

Women have suffered horribly under the tyranny of religion. Hundreds have been killed over nothing more than the length of their hemlines and bikinis are treated as deadly weapons, says Harris. Women are regularly stripped of their rights, worth and even their life simply because of the belief in and the selective interpretation of a book that is purported to be the word of God.

“If a Christian fundamentalist were told that his wife was having an affair or that yogurt makes you invisible, he would want evidence,” Harris writes. “But that same person has no trouble believing in a book that was supposedly written by an invisible man that could subject you to a fiery eternity if you don’t follow it every word.”

Harris asks us to imagine if we were to wake up with all our past knowledge erased and we read the Bible. We would likely be incredulous and frustrated by this confusing, often contradictory, story that justifies and promotes brutal violence against anyone who disagrees with the author’s point of view.

The Old Testament, for instance, demands that Jews kill all those who have not embraced their religion. In other words, God demands that we become serial killers in order to avoid damnation — bad news for DeLay, Frist and Bush who would have us believe that this text is the literal word of God.

“… Palestine (Jews vs. Muslims); The Balkans (Orthodox Serbians vs. Catholic Croatians, Orthodox Serbians vs. Bosnian and Albanian Muslims); Northern Ireland (Protestants vs. Catholics); Kashmir (Muslims vs. Hindus); Sudan (Muslims vs. Christians); Sri Lanka (Sinhalese Buddhists vs. Tamil Hindus); Indonesia (Muslims vs. Timorese Christians); and the Caucasus (orthodox Russians vs. Chechen Muslims, Muslim Azerbaijanis vs. Catholic and orthodox Armenians) …”

Such calls for violence are nearly universal in every religious text, none more so that the Koran, according to Harris. He supports this contention with five pages of passages, which he says appear on nearly every page of the Muslim Holy book, extolling violence and murder.

“Religion is one of the great limiters to moral identity.” Harris writes. “It turns everything into an ‘us against them.’ It eliminates moral concern for those outside the faith. If they are going to hell, who cares what happens to them?”

Which, according to Harris, may explain the glaring similarity between the torture of witches and our treatment of Muslim enemy combatants.

“The idea that religion is the source of our deepest ethical institutions is absurd,” Harris writes. He argues that the origins of ethics come from the natural world and religious teachings are at best equivocal.

Further, Harris suggests that it is only through numbers that behavior that would normally be considered mad. For example, how can the belief in a guy born of a virgin, who walks on water and returns from the dead, who we eat on a cracker each week and who will send us to heaven if we do everything he says, or roast us if we don’t, gain legitimacy?

“Is there any difference,” Harris asks, “between a teen who believes he will receive 72 virgins for blowing himself up and one who is beaming up to the mother ship?”

But the biggest problem with religion, according to Harris, is that any despicable act of brutality or mass murder cannot only be justified, but will provide the perpetrator salvation. This is particularly frightening in a time where there are weapons capable of killing millions and religious fanatics willing to use them.

Can a religious world survive in a nuclear age? Not according to Sam Harris. (Ed Silverstein)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 1, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe