By CAROLE ORLIN
Sunday marked the four-year anniversary of 9-11. For those of us who are old enough to remember back at least to the 1960s, we have lived through four decades of life after the assassination of our national leader John F. Kennedy. Until 9/11, I felt that Nov. 23, 1963, would be the defining historical moment of my lifetime. Then came Sept. 11, 2001. I think that we all immediately recognized that life was never going to be the same for us, for our children and for our grandchildren.
Although life after 9/11 would not and could not be the same as life prior to the attacks on New York City and Washington, D.C. (ironically the former being the city where I grew up, and the latter being the city where I worked for more than 25 years prior to coming to Santa Monica), I was able to see this country coming together in a positive, patriotic fashion. I saw an elected leader take charge after 9/11 in Mayor Rudy Giuliani. I even saw our president, at least for a short period of time, look and sound like a leader. Then, we seemed to be led down a road to an indefinite “war on terrorism” with a starting push in Afghanistan, and a complicated and increasingly unpopular war in Iraq. We have seen ourselves become financially tied to a national Department of Homeland Security, with a commitment to make our country and its citizens more secure and prepared to deal with a multitude of frightening, terrorist scenarios from biological to nuclear weapons, from unprecedented airline security measures to a myriad of changes in the laws that were enacted after 9/11 under the USA Patriot Act of 2001.
We watched last November the reelec-tion of our president with the red states once again trumping the blue states. Then, as we watched our political leaders of both parties and at all levels struggle ineffectively with escalating energy costs, we had Mother Nature take hold and rock us on a local, regional and national level. We have all been watching in horror the handling — or mishandling — of Hurricane Katrina over the last couple of weeks. For me, the most upsetting issue has been the lack of real leadership. When it was clear that the local officials were not able to act swiftly and decisively to provide aid to a large population (spanning three states), who were in need of water, food, medical care and temporary shelter, the president needed to authorize and direct a Giuliani-type leader to take charge. The lack of a coordinated effort of government to react to a significant crisis, after all of the time, effort and money that have been expended since 9/11, is simply unacceptable. It was as if the famous seven-minute “freeze” by President Bush after the World Trade Center attacks turned into days of a similar “freeze” after Hurricane Katrina struck the Gulf Coast. It reminds me of hearing my parents’ old line: “If we can land a man on the moon, why can’t we do x, y or z?”
If government is unable to protect us or assist us in times of widespread emergencies like a biological or chemical attack, or natural disasters arising from hurricanes or earthquakes, tell us that and help us prepare ourselves. I know that Katrina seems to be teaching us many lessons. My confidence in Homeland Security is definitely shaken, as I look at the Katrina disaster as the first real test since 9/11 and see it as a terrible failure. I had been hoping that the billions of dollars that have been devoted to Homeland Security were at least making all of us somewhat safer. Now I am left to wonder what has been really happening. Furthermore, we have been witnessing an ineffective effort at the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), under the direction of its beleaguered head, Michael Brown. The lesson once again, which our presidents from both parties never seem to learn, points to the high stakes of crony-ism. If you are going to select a friend to assist you in a position of power and responsibility, it is critical to ensure that such a selection be overly qualified and highly competent. Apparently, President Bush appears to have not done his homework with regard to Mr. Brown.
As an observer of politics since a very young child growing up in New York, and watching the elections of Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, Carter, Reagan, Bush I, Clinton and Bush II, I keep asking whether the two candidates that run every four years are the best that the country has to offer. With the stakes so high, can we not figure out a better system to permit us to choose from the very best? (Carole)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 12, 2005. Read the original PDF.