By Mike Lipsey Santa Monica
Of late, there has been a great deal of debate over the topic of religion. Clearly, the line is blurred in this day and age about if marriage is a religious ceremony or a civil right. Marriage as an institution began as a religious ceremony in which two couples were joined in a union typically at the satisfaction of whatever God they happen to worship.
Most religions have some sort of ceremony like this. I can’t think of one that does-n’t, but I am admittedly not the most educated man. I do believe that it would be hard to deny the origins of marriage being religious. That being said, as well as our prohibition on religion in the governing of state affairs, leads me to believe that all marriages should not be governed by the federal, state or local governments. Every “marriage” should be recognized as a taxable situation in that two people are sharing income. It would then be labeled legally “civil union” for everyone and the state would clearly not be able to deny that status to any couple, regardless of sex. Well, the term “marriage” is quite well woven into our society — maybe too well to be removed in favor of a label of “civil union” in the government’s eyes.
So, it is simpler to refer to the legal status of two people who are “together” as married as well as their religious status if they so practice. Marriage is a generic term now, not a religious one. It probably wouldn’t hold much water to state otherwise.
We must also note that “separate but equal is not equal” has been held true for decades as a civil right.
If two humans who happen to be the same sex love one another and wish to marry, who are we as a society to stop them? Society determines right and wrong based upon the local values and morals. Local values and morals are driven by the locals themselves. What they think is right is what is right. The values in Los Angeles are clearly different than those in Savannah, Ga., but our basic morals — don’t kill, don’t steal, don’t lie — are all relatively the same.
Discrimination against a person based on race, religion, creed, sex, etc. is illegal. You can’t deny a gay man a driver’s license unless he’s unfit to drive. You can’t deny a gay woman a rental property based on the fact that she’s gay. You can’t not hire either of these people based on their sexuality or their sexual preference. Why then is it legal for our government to deny these people the basic rights we give most everyone in the country? If they want to be together and document it legally that they are together the same way and for the same reasons that I married my wife, who are we to stop them? Regardless of religion, which has no legal bearing on the law, who are we to say this is wrong?
Personally, I will not listen to any religious argument on this subject. Religion and law do not mix. Our forefathers separated church and state for a reason. I respect religion, but I will not have it making my laws.
As far as religion is concerned, they can do what the Boy Scouts do. If you’re gay, you’re not allowed in the Boy Scouts. If you don’t believe in God, you’re not allowed in the Boy Scouts. It’s that simple. It’s their club and if you don’t like their rules, go start your own club. Religion is the same way, the organized religions are under no legal obligation to recognize these marriages or perform them.
Where is the argument now? Being gay just isn’t right? You’ll have to have something better than that. I don’t claim to understand homosexuality, but I’m in no position to deny it either. Frankly, it’s just not up to me to judge these people for how they behave as consenting adults.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.