This Labor Day, it’s worth recounting a recent news story that many Americans might have missed. Last month, employees at a Wal-Mart store in Saguenay, Quebec (a city about 100 miles north of Quebec City known more for its skiing than labor activism) became the first among the retail giant’s 1.3 million employees to gain union representation.
Not one other of the company’s 4,800 North American stores has a union. But Quebec does not boast the continent’s only unionized Wal-Mart store because Canadian employees like unions more than their counterparts in the United States. Indeed, a recent book by the renowned social scientist, Seymour Martin Lipset, argues that the opposite is true: The Paradox of American Unionism demonstrates that approval for unions is significantly lower north of the border. Rather, the Quebec employees succeeded where U.S. Wal-Mart employees have failed because, unlike its U.S. counterpart, Quebec labor law provides real protection for the right to choose a union.
The Saguenay employees were able to form a union by signing authorization cards indicating that a clear majority wanted independent representation, thereby limiting the ability of the company to influence the outcome. In the United States, employees are forced to go through lengthy and bitter election campaigns, and companies like Wal-Mart spend millions of dollars during these campaigns attempting to “persuade” their employees to reject the union.
But this is not just a story of how U.S. law fails to protect employees against the actions of aggressively anti-union employers. It is also about how the company profits at the taxpayers’ expense. As a result of its low-wage, anti-union business strategy, Wal-Mart’s employees earn about 30 percent less than unionized retail employees and are much less likely to be covered by employer-sponsored health insurance.
In 2001, Wal-Mart sales clerks earned an average of $13,861 — almost $1,000 below the federal poverty line for a family of three. But Wal-Mart’s ruthless employment practices don’t only affect its own employees — they hurt all taxpayers, who, more often than not, are forced to pick up the tab.
A recent study by the UC Berkeley Labor Center estimates that Wal-Mart’s employment practices cost California $86 million per year in public assistance to company workers. California’s 44,000 Wal-Mart employees rely on state assistance for about $32 million per year in health-related services and $54 million in other services, such as subsidized school lunches for their children, food stamps and subsidized housing. And as other retail employers struggle to compete with Wal-Mart (an issue that was at the heart of the recent supermarket strike in southern California), the financial burden on taxpayers is likely to increase substantially.
If Wal-Mart employees in California and the rest of the United States enjoyed the same legal rights as their Quebec counterparts, taxpayers might no longer be forced to subsidize the “low-road” employment practices of world’s largest corporation, which posted $245 billion in revenues in 2002. Now, that would be worth celebrating next Labor Day. (The author teaches industrial relations at the London School of Economics).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 6, 2004. Read the original PDF.