Skip to content

Hair color is beside the point

Published:

By Scott D. Allen

Professor Edwin Locke in his Martin Luther King Day “tribute” (SMDP, Jan. 19, page 7) goes a long way to make a statement abhorring racism and equating affirmative action as synonymous. His views and justifications are as transparent as the “glass ceiling” affirmative action is designed to remove.

I can only assume that professor Locke is a European-American over the age of, say, 50. His credentials are noteworthy and his analysis is balanced, but horribly unrealistic. The professor emeritus uses, for example, a fictional case history in which a company whose time line is squarely within the lifespan of my grandparents and parents (nearly 70 years ago) discriminates on the basis of hair color. Hair color. Hair color, the most superficial of all inherent human traits is easily alterable and often is. Especially if doing so affords one a preferred quality of life hence the phrase, “blondes have more fun.”

His argument most certainly would have carried more credibility if the qualifier were height, or language, or even weight — a trait many of us no matter what creed would argue has never been as easily alterable as we would like.

As a Spanish-speaking African American, I find it quite insulting (to my intelligence, for starters) that someone with a preferred citizen status as a birth right finds fault with a system that provides it to those who’ve been denied the same systematically for nearly half a millennium. To go further and equate the stigmatic and unalterable trait (unless you’re a musical icon with mega-wealth) of skin color and origin with something as superficial as hair color — which in the 21st century is as changeable as clothing — is preposterous.

And to do so on this day which honors a man, whose fight for equal rights for all people cost him his life, is equally distasteful.

I’d like to mention, ironically, that I have a niece who is in her senior year at the University of Maryland at College Park where Professor Locke was tenured. She is a brilliant young lady on the Dean’s list, pre-law, and will graduate with honors this spring — the pride of our family in my hometown of Baltimore. She is the product of both affirmative action and my sister’s hard earned tuition dollars. The Law Schools of Harvard or Yale would be privileged to enroll such a promising graduate student, “hair color” not withstanding.

The long-term effects of centuries old institutionalized racism didn’t and will not disappear with 40 years of legislation (affirmative action), but it’s a start. Racism begins and ends with power — those who have it versus those who don’t.

The National Football League, whose 31 franchises/teams are comprised of an ownership group which is at least 99 percent white, has instituted a policy by which any team with a head coaching vacancy is to interview at least two minority candidates. Is this a quota system? Yes it is. Is it warranted in a major sport where the body of athletes is 78 percent black? Of course it is. And as a result, this fall will see the highest number of active African American head coaches in League history (five). Two of the five coaches have been instrumental in winning a Super Bowl in the last five years. At least three have led a team to the playoffs in the last ten years either as a head coach or a coordinator (I’ve done my homework professor). Is that progress? Absolutely. And for all of the ills of professional sports, this is a step in the right direction.

Professor Locke, if you can continue to question the validity or the necessity to level the playing field to allow the qualified of all races to compete fairly, not only do I question your logic, but I take offense to your over-simplification of the greatest crisis facing the country I’ve served in peace-time and war. Your misinformed position is only redeemed by the fact that you are unmistakably not listed as a professor of history because then I would be forced to challenge (to quote Dr. Martin Luther King) “the content of your character.”

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 22, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe