Skip to content

Have you considered a lease bond?

Published:

By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER

As all landlords know, how and by whom a lease is secured is key to any lease negotiation. There is a relatively new form of lease securitization being used called a “lease bond.” In short, a lease bond is a contract between three parties: the landlord, the tenant and a surety underwriter, securing a tenant’s financial performance in lieu of a cash security deposit, a personal or corporate guarantee, or a letter of credit. A lease bond is usually issued by a creditworthy party such as an insurance company and can guarantee either all or some of the tenant’s obligations — usually only monetary.

From a tenant’s standpoint, the lease bond could be appealing for a few reasons: ■ One-time issuance fee compared to an annual renewal fee for a letter of credit of which the cost can be unpredictable. ■ No cash tied up in a security deposit. ■ No liability shown on a tenant’s financial statements, preserving its borrowing capacity. ■ Any claim against the tenant by the landlord would be against the issuing entity, not the tenant. ■ No personal guarantee required. From a landlord’s standpoint, the lease bond could be appealing because: ■ In addition to the financial ability of the tenant, the landlord has the superior credit of an insurance company. ■ Easier to evaluate the issuer’s credit. ■ The proceeds from a lease bond, currently, are not subject to the jurisdiction of a bankruptcy court, or customarily regarded as an asset of the tenant, making it considerably easier to collect on a claim against a bankrupt tenant.

As pointed out by Mark A. Senn in “Commercial Real Estate Leases: Preparation, Negotiation and Forms,” the lease bond is a new legal instrument so that practical utility and legal value are unsettled. There may be substantial cost and delays in negotiating the circumstances and terms on which the bond can be called. Another significant point he makes is that lease bonds are usually offered by insurance companies, the same people whose business is the avoidance of paying claims and whose fame in legal circles is for the establishment of the modern law of surety ship defenses to claims on their contracts.

I think that a landlord, given a choice, will choose a letter of credit. Ordinarily the letter of credit will obligate the issuer to honor a draw request without questioning the landlord’s right to receive it. With a lease bond, the surety is entitled to take the tenant’s side and resolve any dispute prior to paying any claim.

With the condition of the market moving away from a tenant’s market and closer to equilibrium a tenant’s ability to negotiate away from a letter of credit may be challenged, unless, of course, there are other motivating factors pushing the landlord toward the lease bond. (The above is for informational purposes only and not meant to be taken as advice. Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling office and industrial properties and (310) 806-6104 or)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 2, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe