By Eric Cooper Santa Monica Nail all religions to the cross Editor:
Ed Silverstein’s big complaint in his latest column, (SMDP, Feb. 25, page 4), is that Mel Gibson cherry picked certain Gospel passages that backed up what he wanted to say. He further emphasizes that the Gospels were written several decades after the crucifixion, implying that they might not be accurate.
Given the fact that the movie came out this week (and not several decades ago) Silverstein has the opportunity to be much more accurate. There are literally hundreds of expert sources to choose from this week from TV, print and radio. Silverstein has the opportunity to show us how a fair depiction of a major event is done.
So did he present a balanced and fair account of what experts say about “The Passion?” No. In his effort to crucify the film, he didn'’t give one source that supported “The Passion,” only sources that support his biased slant.
Silverstein plays the anti-Semite card without pointing out that most Jewish leaders do not consider the film, nor Gibson, to be anti-Semitic (Dennis Prager, Michael Medved and several Jewish experts on Diane Sawyer’s interview with Mel, to name but a few).
Furthermore, all Christian leaders have gone out of their way to say that the Jews are not to blame, but rather that Jesus died for all our sins.
Seems to me, Silverstein is guilty of the very cherry picking that you rant against.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.