By Giles Smith Santa Monica
Regarding the city’s attempt to enforce code restrictions on front yard hedges, some misleading statements have been made, and a clarification is in order.
There are lots of code restrictions on the front yard of residences. Generally, the front of the house must be set back 20 feet from the sidewalk. The owner’s use of that space is further restricted in many ways: You can’t park cars on the lawn, you can’t raise poultry or livestock, etc. The notion that a restriction on hedge height is some kind of exceptional infringement on property rights is clearly wrong, as is the notion that code restrictions should be enforced only if someone complains. The only thing exceptional about the restriction on hedge height is that the law has not been fully enforced for many years, and some people are surprised to learn that such a restriction exists. That is hardly justification for continued violation of the law.
Like many other code restrictions, the limit of hedge height in front yards is not just as capricious and silly exercise in bureaucracy. It is part of a broader attempt to impose certain aesthetic standards on the neighborhood. Whether this particular standard is appropriate and desirable is certainly subject to debate, but that debate should be on the merits of the rule. Many of us who live in the area think it is a good rule and should be enforced. We like the open vistas and neighborly feeling provided by our ability to see each other, rather than being enclosed by a wall of high hedges.
So let’s have a debate about the rule on front yard hedges, but let’s recognize that there are some benefits to the present rule and that many of us favor it. Implying that it is a silly rule, uniformly abhorred by everyone, is wrong.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.