Things we find in the woods may remind us of what we are
By CAROLINE BODKIN
I visited my best friend in her home-town last weekend.
She’s living, as she calls it, fancy free, finishing the classes she needs before applying to grad school and dating someone who’s not entirely practical. She recently broke up with her boyfriend, steady boyfriend, future lawyer boyfriend, could-be-a-father-to-her-children boyfriend, of five years.
We took a walk through the Vermont woods as we talked about the break-up. She picked up stones and rubbed them between her fingers meditatively and suddenly she started singing (this is something she’s done ever since I’ve known her) to the trees, to the sky, to the stone in her hand, a song of nothing and everything, just words as they came to her, to a tune she made up as I watched.
Her voice was untrained but beautiful, rough, entirely her own, joyful.
I smiled and started singing with her and when we were done (we’d reached the small waterfall by this time) she laughed and said, “He hated it when I used to sing in public. It always made him cringe.”
They broke up, she said, because he was headed into a life that she couldn’t see herself living in. He’s a neat freak, a Boston socialite, a natural born conservative and she’s not.
She’s wild and rowdy and remarkable and she knew that being with him would often mean toning herself down, living far away from her rural home, attending lawyerly dinners, impressing bosses.
At some point, she had to decide if living that life meant she’d be giving up too much of herself.
All relationships are give and take. A good one will take you to the moon, but in order to get there you inevitably have to give things up. You might give up Sunday night football in favor of date night, or your habit of eating ice cream for dinner when it’s your turn to cook.
These are not big sacrifices. They are easy to identify, and with minimal compromise — i.e. football and date night on alternating Sundays — life together remains possible.
Other losses or sacrifices are much more slippery. People lose them over time, or without knowing they’re being lost because they’re small pieces of yourself you may not miss until they’re gone.
For example, maybe you like to sing in public. Maybe singing loudly brings you joy. But you do it one time, and it embarrasses your boyfriend or girlfriend and so you stop — not only that one time, but all together.
And then after a while, singing in public seems like a silly thing to do.
And over time you change into someone who just doesn’t sing in public. And maybe that’s no big deal. Singing may not have been your first love, or your life’s ambition, and maybe you’ll forget you ever sang. Maybe that sacrifice feels insignificant compared to the joy you get from never embarrassing your girlfriend or boyfriend.
But maybe... it’s possible that you won’t forget you once sang. Maybe you’ll wake up one morning believing you could’ve been great at it, and you’re upset you never moved to New York to try it on Broadway and you wonder what life would have been like if you’d been with someone who encouraged you — who pushed you even — to try.
Or if not that, at least you’ll wonder why your someone didn’t just smile and reach for your hand while you sang.
Singing is just something she did once in a while. It didn’t define her as a person, it wasn’t her life’s ambition, and she might have stopped without noticing after a year or two.
How do we draw that line between things that we just do, and things that we are? How do we identify the things we can give up that won’t ultimately feel like a real loss?
We’d been walking through the woods for almost an hour — in silence now. We weren’t aware of the time, or the date, or the things we were supposed to be doing right then.
We were happy. It’s not your partner’s job to make sure you do what makes you happy. It’s your job not to let them stop you. It’s your job to keep singing. And maybe it’ll stop bothering them.
Maybe after a while they’ll reach for your hand and listen. Or maybe they’ll distance themselves from you to avoid embarrassment (like he did). Or maybe some day they’ll open their mouths to the sky and join in. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wants to hear you sing. You can )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 20, 2004. Read the original PDF.