Skip to content

Hip to be square

Published:

Real Christmas means looking beyond the phonies

By CAROLINE BODKIN

I love the holidays. I love family, I love cookies, and I love the way a house smells with a tree in it. I love spending entire afternoons thinking about just one person as I shop for his or her gift. I love wrapping. I love elves.

I love it all. This year, right after Thanksgiving, I’ll begin my celebrations early. I’ll kick-start my Christmas spirit by buying a whole stack of holiday-themed magazines so I can spend any spare moments looking for fun gift ideas or good mulled cider recipes.

The magazines, their saturated colors and the portrayals of the ideal holiday are mesmerizing. All that gloss, all that cheer. Man, those pictures are beautiful. Wreathes on the door, fire in the fireplace, a warm, happy family unwrapping carefully chosen, high-quality presents. This, to me is what a real Christmas looks like.

I wanted one. A real Christmas of my own. Some day. I’ll really go for it, give my decorating hand a try and make my home a little place of warmth, my family the recipients of thoughtful, maybe even hand-crafted gifts. I’ll have a real Christmas family and a real Christmas. This is my daydream.

The images all around me in the magazines and commercials have become part of my daydream from years past. I paid close attention to them, taking mental notes of what a real Christmas looked like, knowing I’d have one some day.

I’d have a real Christmas. Real Christmas was beautiful. It was perfect.

And yet, even with all this daydreaming, it terrifies me.

Because I’m not a decorating genius. I’m not even a homemaker, nor am I Santa’s Helper. And I can’t afford fancy gifts, I don’t have time to make my own wreathes or knit my own stockings, so I know my holiday will fall short. My home will never be as lavishly decorated. My cookies will never be as moist. My gifts will never be as gracious. My Christmas will never be as real.

These thoughts saddened me. It didn’t bring me to tears or ruin my day. It was the kind of sadness that a kid might feel when being chosen last in gym class. I felt unpopular and unskilled.

So I tried to accept my shortcomings and let go of my fantasy, but I couldn’t escape these images of the real Christmas. They were everywhere, all the time.

Then, two days ago as I was passing through a very nice neighborhood, I came across a film shoot. Cameras and lights were set up in a beautiful old Craftsman. I asked someone what was going on, and they told me it was a Christmas commercial for a certain card company. You know, the one who practically owns the holiday.

I stood there, zoning out, just gazing at the house. I could see through the open front door. I stared at its beautifully decorated inside. Perfect tree. Perfect wreath. Perfectly wrapped presents. This, I thought again, is what a real Christmas looks like.

Breaking me from my reverie, one of the producers yelled at someone to retrieve the talent from their dressing room. A man scampered over to a nearby RV, knocked on a few doors, and after a second, two adults and three children emerged: A handsome man; a beautiful woman with red curly hair; a very cute little boy who looked like the man; and two girls, roughly 3 years apart and very similar looking, with cute curly hair like the woman’s.

This was the family to match the house, the tree, the gifts. The real Christmas family.

That’s when it hit me. As I watched the groomed and perfectly assembled “family” walk toward the perfectly decorated, very warm “home” to recreate this company’s vision of what America’s Christmas should be, I realized... This isn’t a real family. This isn’t their house. They did not put up those decorations. This is not where they’ll celebrate Christmas.

I thought about my own family’s Christmas. I thought about my loved ones’ Christmases. I thought about mixed families and divorced families and non- Christian families and families who can’t afford gifts and families who choose to only give one, the people who work at soup kitchens on Christmas Day and the people who need them and the people like me who don’t have the decorating gene.

A million images of Christmas came to mind. Some of them looked like the inside of that well decorated set, and some of them did not. But all were good. All were right.

All were real. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and will see snow for Christmas. You can send your comments to her at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 29, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe