Skip to content

Historical perspective on worker’s compensation

Published:

By Sen. Sheila Kuehl

(This is the fourth in a series of columns by California State Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica) regarding the state budget).

In 1911, out of concern that injured workers had to sue to get any kind of care and compensation for workplace injuries, the Legislature created a voluntary workman’s comp plan. Virtually no one took advantage of it, so in 1913, a no-fault workman’s comp system mandated that all employers provide coverage. Injured workers were to have a way to get treatment and return to work. Employers pushed for adoption of the system, because it would preclude the worker from taking an employer to court for an injury. The workman’s comp system was to be the exclusive remedy for workplace injuries and payments for temporary and permanent disability that stemmed from a workplace injury.

The state compensation fund was created as an insurer of last resort and a minimum rate was established so insurance companies couldn’t “compete” in a race to the bottom for rates and then go belly up. Eighty years later, the worker’s comp system was deregulated, and the minimum rate law went away. Insurance companies flooded the market, premiums dropped and a number of companies fell out of the market, leaving only a few solvent companies. The state fund began picking up more of the market. Insurance companies, which had been staying solvent by investing premiums in a very healthy stock market, got hit by the bust, lost a great deal after 9-11 in other insurance losses and, by 2001, 27 companies had gone bankrupt. Those that were left restricted their policies, raised their rates and stopped writing new policies. The state fund was up to covering 55 percent of the market, including 80 percent of small businesses.

At the same time, skyrocketing medical costs, experienced by everyone, cost the insurance companies more in pay-outs. Although there were fewer claims in 2002 than in 2001, the average medical cost per injured worker had risen from $45,000 to $52,000. Many complained that there were really no incentives to return to work, and there were delays in providing treatment. Employers complained that they were being wrung dry by the premiums and many blamed “generous benefits to workers” and “fraud.” Interestingly, however, every person, on both sides of the argument, who came to speak before our committees testified that “we have the highest premiums in the country and the worst coverage for workers in the country.” Many complained that permanent disability benefits were to blame. Injured workers, however, pointed out that the percentage of growth in premiums was much higher than the percentage of growth in medical costs and disability benefits combined. They asked for controls on the premiums charged by insurance companies so they were more in line with actual costs.

Last year, convinced that some of the coverage related to chiropractic care, outpatient surgery centers, pharmaceutical costs and vocational rehabilitation mandates had created some of the high costs in the system, the Legislature made several cuts in benefits for injured workers, with an estimated savings of between $8 and $11 billion. No controls were placed on premiums.

The insurance companies did not agree with our assessment of savings, and they maintained that the reduction in their costs would be far less. They also argued that it did not pass any savings on to employers in the form of premium decreases. Most companies indicated that they had been planning to raise premiums again by double digits and, instead, only raised them by single digits. Injured workers still had less coverage. Litigation time did not decrease, since funding reductions and hiring freezes meant no new judges or staff could be hired. No one was happy.

Our new governor promised to fix everything, one way or the other. The next column will address whether that will happen.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe