Skip to content

Law firm honored for defeating Santa Monica living wage measure

Published:

By Michael J. Tittinger

“God cannot alter the past, but historians can.” — Samuel Butler Thumbing through Joseph J. Ellis’ Pulitzer Prize winning book “Founding Brothers,” an eloquent account of the birth of the United States, I am struck by the fact that each of the vignettes focuses on men, the artists formerly known as “Founding Fathers.” So why then are our children going to be instructed to refer to them solely as “Framers,” an abstract description that conjures images of yeoman woodworkers toiling away in a pre-air conditioning workshop?

These men — George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson and the like — were by most accounts, indeed men (what they did behind closed stable doors is anyone’s guess), but suddenly we appear skittish to call them just that.

The political correctness police are in full swing once again, this time taking direct aim at our schoolchildren in the form of reshaping history. A textbook review process taking place in several states, including California, is attempting to rename everything from “Snow men” (to “Snow people.” I guess the late Gene Autry would have to change his tune these days) and wiping out other historical feats, such as Mount Rushmore, altogether, because it may or may not offend some Native-American groups.

Let’s call it a kinder, gentler American history. his*to*ry n., pl., -ries 1. A narrative of events. 2. A chronological record of events. 3. The branch of knowledge that records and analyzes past events. 4. The events of the past. 5. An interesting past.

Am I missing the part about “as long as it doesn’t offend?”

There’s an old adage that wisely warns us to learn from our history, lest we are doomed to repeat it. Or was it, if we don’t redefine our history, we are bound to not like it? Hmm. Yes, history can be grim, unpleasant, even, dare I say, politically incorrect. Sometimes it is hard to look at, but don’t we learn more from our mistakes than our failures? We are showing ever less confidence in our children’s cognitive abilities to not only learn, but also decipher what they learn on their own and draw their own conclusions.

As we bend over backwards to sanitize the past in obvious efforts to please every ethnic group and every unfortunate soul that history has stepped on over the years, we are in turn stripping away any confidence we put in our educators and our children to process the information for what it is — history. Not to mention the further dissolution of our disparate cultures, which we blatantly fight so hard to recognize and celebrate.

The outright avoidance of topics such as Mount Rushmore, where the faces of four American presidents carved into stone overlook lands once dominated by the subsequently oppressed American natives, is just plain wrong. If it offends, why does it offend? What better way to segue into the historical mistreatment of Native Americans than a landmark still revered by so many Americans today? Unless we plan to unfurl a black sheath over the site in the Black Hills, children are gonna see it. We can’t protect them from the sins of the past forever.

Of course, they won’t be learning much about American Indians anyway, as textbooks will no longer be depicting them in braids, living on reservations or in rural settings. These images offend all those short-haired, urban dwelling tribes of yore, I assume. Only problem there, according to historians, is that many American Indians did wear their hair in braids and live on reservations. And reviewers offer no alternative suggestions on just how to depict the Native- Americans. Maybe that brainstorm will emerge from further closed-door meetings and book burnings.

The historical cleansing, if you will, is but just one facet of the sweeping changes in language being proposed amid the review process. Gone will be pictures of such food items as soda, hot dogs, butter and cakes — foods not part of a theorized well-balanced diet. Poof! They’re gone as if they didn’t exist. The word “yacht” is now deemed elitist. The term senior citizen is just plain antiquated. Now we have “older persons.” Try hitting grandma with that one next time you kiss her on the cheek. Of course, I always thought the cumbersome “senior citizen” was the politically correct answer to “old people.”

Pressure groups, both from the Democratic and Republican camps, are lobbying legislators to sign off on these changes. Unfortunately, their movement seems to be gathering steam.

“It dumbs down our textbooks,” author Diane Ravitch was quoted as telling Fox News. Ravitch has written extensively on the issue of language changes in American scholastic textbooks. “It makes them bland, far less interesting than anything children might see in the movies, even in G-rated movies or TV.

“It’s outright censorship,” she added.

The respective textbook publishers’ hands are admittedly tied, for if they refuse to adopt the changes proposed by such states as California, they face an uncertain economic future. As a result, they find themselves increasingly removing the sources of controversy from their publications to address individual complaints from an increasingly oversensitive populace.

Those who defend the changes will undoubtedly counter that textbooks should remain free of any ethnic stereotyping, no matter that the very stereotype was borne from historical accuracy. Or that men and women should be represented equally, no matter that society was different in the past when men and women assumed far different roles.

In effect, we are projecting today’s beliefs and morals on our ancestors, when we have no right doing so. It’s the stuff of a Monty Python or Mel Brooks film, which were made all-the-more hysterical by their juxtaposition of modern beliefs and behaviors in ancient times.

“Don’t get saucy with me, Bernaise.” I guess some people didn’t get the jokes.

God forbid, (whoops, better not use his name, er, it’s name, er… Better just start this sentence again.) If our goal was to produce a cookie-cutter society whereby our sons and daughters have been so homogenized that they lack the wherewithal to be taught the truth and be critical of the past, then I would say we are on the right track.

Well, at least our world has been delivered from evil in the process, as you won’t find any more mention of a certain red-horned figure with a pitchfork. (Mike Tittinger is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. To reach him, ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 8, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe