By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOHN MARCIANO COMMUNITY BRIEFS
Since President Bush’s reelection, Christian conservatives have renewed their call for Americans to return to that time when religion and morality had a greater influence on our civic life. This call rests on the fundamental premise that Christian “moral values,” based on Biblical teaching, promotes a more decent society, and we have strayed from these guiding principles. Indeed, if such conservative values have engendered more humane social and political policies, one must ask: When did they prevail?
Was it in 1776, when the “inalienable rights” of the Declaration of Independence were denied in practice to indentured servants and other poor whites, women, slaves, free blacks and Native Americans?
Was it 1787, when the newly ratified Constitution, supposedly built upon religion and morality, affirmed the enslavement of black people, excluded Indians and women, and established the supremacy of the rich and powerful?
Was it 1790, when the U.S. Congress declared that only whites could become naturalized citizens?
Was it in 1838, when some 17,000 Cherokee were forcibly removed from their homes and sent on a death march that killed nearly half of them in the “Trail of Tears?”
Was it during the 1840s and 1850s, when Anglos made California a state and killed thousands of Indians in the process, kidnapping their children and continuing the old Spanish custom of raping Indian women?
Was it 1857, when the Supreme Court ruled that Dred Scott could not sue for his freedom because, as a slave, he was property and not a person?
Was it in 1882, when Congress barred the immigration of Chinese laborers to the U.S., a measure that was supported unanimously by Congress-men from the South and West?
Was it 1890, when the U.S. cavalry massacred 350 unarmed Lakota Sioux at Wounded Knee, South Dakota — mostly women, children and old men? The massacre was lauded by L. Frank Baum, author of the “Wizard of Oz” and editor of the “Aberdeen Saturday Pioneer,” who stated that “we had better, in order to protect our civilization, follow it up … and wipe these untamed and untamable creatures from the face of the earth.”
Was it 1900, when the U.S., facing resistance by the vast majority of Filipinos to our imperialist and racist aggression, reacted by “resettling populations in concentration camps, burning down villages … and engaging in mass hangings and bayoneting of suspects, systematic rape of women and girls, and torture?” Perhaps 250,000 Filipinos, mostly civilians, were killed in that “splendid little war.”
Was it 1922, when the Supreme Court ruled that a Japanese man could not become a naturalized citizen because he was “clearly not Caucasian?”
Was it the 1920s, when the Ku Klux Klan had millions of members, including prominent U.S. political officials, and lynching and other acts of terror against blacks were common in the South and the Midwest?
Was it during the 1930s and 1940s, when untold thousands of Jews attempting to flee Nazi Germany were prevented from entering the U.S. because immigration barriers were not removed?
Was it after World War II, when apartheid terror continued to rule education and social life in the South — the self-proclaimed center of Christian “moral values?”
Was it the 1960s, when laws barred interracial marriage in the South?
That bigotry has shifted from interracial couples to gays and lesbians, as Christian conservatives who oppose gay marriage are the not-too-distant relatives of those who once claimed it was morally wrong for blacks and whites to marry. These Christians now include some Black ministers who will “gather in the first of regional summits to build support for banning same-sex marriage” (Los Angeles Times, Feb. 1, 2005). Appeals to God and the Bible to deny marriage to blacks and whites were bankrupt; they remain no less bankrupt today when homophobic black ministers wish to deny fundamental human rights to gays and lesbians.
Or was it 1964 in Mississippi, when James Chaney, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner were kidnapped, beaten and murdered for helping blacks register to vote?
We could recite hundreds of other facts about U.S. history that document an indisputable conclusion: Every effort in American history to enlarge equality and freedom for all has been opposed by Christian conservatives. Their ceaseless pontification about “moral values” is a testament to the profound historical amnesia and civic illiteracy to which we have succumbed — created and sustained by a corporate mass media, educational and religious institutions.
When American history is examined truthfully, we see that Christian conservatives have defended slavery and the subjugation of non-European racial minorities in the U.S. They have opposed equality for women, using appeals to God and the Bible to justify their pervasive misogyny.
They have opposed efforts to improve the conditions of working people — including the formation of labor unions, minimum-wage legislation, child-labor protection and safety regulations.
Christian conservatives have supported every racist war in U.S. history, including the nearly 300-year conflict against Native Americans that ended with the massacre at Wounded Knee.
If we reject the historical myths taught in schools and reported in the mass media, we must ask some fundamental questions: How is it that Christian conservatives who have been on the wrong side of every important struggle in our history presume to lecture us about right and wrong? How did they pull off one of the great cons of all time: That they stand for compassion, decency and justice? (John Marciano lives in Santa Monica).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 19, 2005. Read the original PDF.