By Connie Dawson
Sometimes lessons can be learned by working backward. When we see adult behavior that is annoying, hurtful or inept, we say, “I wouldn’t want our children to grow up to be like that. I’d like to spare them the pain.”
Here’s a case study on Melissa: She is 50-something and was divorced last year. She finds herself in a cloud of confusion, asking, “What on earth happened?” Not so much about her marriage, but about her credit card balance. Melissa has managed to accrue a debt that has finally gotten her attention. And now she’s worried.
Let me tell you a few things about Melissa. Her house is a pleasure to the eye. She says she only feels special in an outfit the first time she wears it. She lives alone now and every closet, even the one in the front hall, is crowded with her clothes.
Melissa reminisces about the special time spent with her mother as a little girl. “Almost every Saturday, we’d go shopping. She loved to get clothes for me. Everything matched, from hair ribbons to shoes. She loved to put a new outfit on me and then my father would take me for walks in the neighborhood, stopping to talk with anyone we saw. They all paid attention to me. ‘Isn’t she just darling!’ ‘You are so cute!’ My father would be all smiles.”
Now grown up, Melissa says, “When I see something I like, I want to buy it. How do you decide whether or not to buy something? I really want to know. I really want to know. I can’t continue to buy what I can’t pay for.”
I thought for a minute. Hmmm. How do I decide to buy something? For starters, I ask myself these questions: ■ Is this a want or a need? ■ If it’s a want, can I return to buy it if it turns out I need it? ■ Can I afford it? I pay off my credit card balance each month. If I can’t pay for what I want to buy at the end of the month, I don’t buy it.
“How did you learn that?” Melissa asked.
Another challenging question: “Unlike your family, my family didn’t have the option of spending money for things we didn’t absolutely need. I watched my parents worry about how to spend the money they had. They hated debt. How much to spend on what is probably based on what I learned from my parents. I hate the stress I have when I’m in debt.”
“Well,” Melissa said, “my parents were proud of how good I looked and proud of my good taste. My husband would fuss about how much I spent, but he never said ‘no.’ We only had one really big fight about my spending when I bought a coat he considered outrageously expensive. But now, I’m on my own. No one is bailing me out, and I’m in trouble.”
Check it out Test your understanding of overindulgence by putting Melissa’s situation as a child to the “Test of Four:” A “yes” to any of the four questions is a red flag the situation is probably one of overindulgence.
Did her parents’ behavior: ■ Hinder Melissa’s development? ■ Require a disproportionate share of family resources? ■ Benefit the parents more than Melissa? ■ Harm others, the planet, (or in this case, Melissa as an adult)?
Yes, Melissa was overindulged as a child. As an adult, she has needed good reason to learn the skills she didn’t learn in childhood.
Melissa’s parents did not intend to cause their much-loved daughter pain in her adult life. Nonetheless, that’s what happened. All parents can learn to avoid the long-term hazards of overindulging out of love for their children. The earlier children learn the lessons that will help them be successful, the better for them and us. (Connie Dawson, Jean Illsley Clarke and David Bredehoft are co-authors of “How Much Is Enough? Everything You Need to Know to Steer Clear of Overinduolgence and Raise Likeable, Responsible and Respectful Children.” Dawson To read more about overindulgence, go to www.overindulgence.info.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 3, 2005. Read the original PDF.