By Abby Arnold Santa Monica
I read with interest your (July 1) article about the relationship (or lack thereof) between state efforts to reduce the number of students in elementary and secondary school classes, and achievement on test scores. It is time to challenge the assumption that scores on norm-referenced, multiple-choice standardized test have any value in assessing the education that goes on in a classroom.
In regard to the SAT-9, which until now has been used as the measure for judging California schools and students as “good” or “bad,” I’d like to make the following comments: ■The SAT-9 is marked on a curve, and any question that is answered correctly by “too many” students is not scored. Half of all test-takers will fail, or score “below average,” which certainly contradicts President Bush’s promise to “leave no child behind.” ■CalCARE, an education organization, called the questions on the SAT-9 “simple, obscure, boring, irrelevant, out-of-context, random, and ambiguous. One could easily make the case for more than one correct answer, and it also contains information that is simply wrong.” ■Experts say that the SAT-9 is only a measure of the socio-economic status and educational attainment of the parents whose children take the test. This factor is particularly pernicious, because test scores are used to label schools, neighborhoods, and communities as “good” or “bad,” when what is reflected by the label is the ethnicity and education of the community.
There are so many better ways of determining whether students are learning. I urge you to go to the SMMUSD’s district office and look at the student work on display there to get a sense of how well our students learn, or to engage in a discussion with a student from any district school. There isn’t a shortcut to assessing learning, and the standardized tests currently in use in California are certainly not a substitute for authentic assessment.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 10, 2002. Read the original PDF.