Skip to content

How to strike a balance in the mortgage rate game

Published:

By Jodi Summers

Do you know how mortgage rates are determined? Sure, you’re quick to blame the usual suspects — the banks, the mortgage brokers, and mortgage packagers like Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac — not to mention Alan Greenspan and the Federal Reserve. The accused, in tandem with several dozen others would be what influences mortgage rates.

“Rates are moved by a number of related factors, and believe it or not, you — Joe or Jane Consumer — are one of those factors,” observed a spokesperson for HSH Associates, the nation’s largest publisher of mortgage and consumer loan information. “Mortgage money can come from many sources, including deposits at banks and brokerages, but most comes from investors through what is collectively known as the ‘capital markets.’ This is where investors interested in purchasing certain kinds of debt instruments — bonds, in this case — come to buy these items.”

Mortgage rates are influenced by the value of money. To get investors to buy mortgage-backed securities, sellers must offer rates of interest that are competitive with alternative interest-paying investments such as treasury bonds. Thus, it is not uncommon for the mortgage originator to sell its loan to an institution that packages it with other mortgages into what’s known as a mortgage-backed security. Then it sells that sweetened security to investors.

“That investor, whether it’s a mutual fund or a large institutional investor, earns a return by collecting the principal and interest payments that you and all the other mortgage borrowers make,” explains Walter Updegrave, a financial expert who writes for Money Magazine.

You might assume that, since a 30-year mortgage has the same term as a 30-year treasury bond, mortgage rates might track the rates on long-term treasury securities. On average, 30-year mortgages remain outstanding about 10 to 12 years, so rates on 30-year mortgages tend to track the yields on 10-year treasury notes.

The next variable — mortgage borrowers aren’t as good a credit risk as the government, so rates on 10-year mortgages are higher than those on 10-year treasuries. In general, 30-year mortgage rates are about two percentage points higher, but that spread can vary.

Investors have hundreds, if not thousands of places to park their money, which is why supply and demand for a given kind of investment plays a considerable role in moving market yields. Dot.com, biotech, real estate — investor demand for a specific product rises and falls with changes in investment strategies. If demand falls enough, a change needs to be made to attract investors again. This means raising interest rates.

The delicate balance is that the mortgage market makers serve not one client, but two: Investors, who want the highest possible return on their investments and the homeowner who wants the lowest possible interest rate.

Simultaneously, rates need to be high enough to attract investors but low enough to attract borrowers. Inflation is an additional factor that can affect interest rates. If inflation is on the rise, interest rates also will rise because inflation dilutes the future value of the fixed interest payments the investors will receive.

Investors want protection in the form of higher interest payments, thus higher rates for borrowers. If there are no inflation trends, investors may accept lower rates.

As interest rates decline, investors may lose interest — depending upon the direction of economic growth, inflation, supply, demand, etc. Typically, the lower the rate of return, the fewer investors are interested in committing.

Last week, Labor Secretary Elaine Chao told CNNfn, slow job growth would likely delay any interest-rate hike by the Federal Reserve.

For more details on the factors that go into mortgage rates, check out the HSH Web site: http://www.hsh.com/pamphlets/mortgage_movements.html. (, or call (310) 309-4219).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 24, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe