By Guest Commentary By Tom Larmore
(This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance in July of 2001 requiring business located in the coastal zone that generate $5 million or more in revenue to pay their employees up to $12.25 per hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded which is before voters this November.) Suppose a city passed a law stating that only those holding college degrees would be permitted to hold jobs in that community. While this would insure that only college graduates obtained jobs, we would have no difficulty judging such a law to be immoral and, presumably, illegal.
Suppose instead that a law was passed establishing a minimum wage in that city of $50 per hour. While this might have a similar result, or at least limit job opportunities to those with substantial skills of one kind or another, we would probably all recognize that such a law would be adverse to the community’s interest. Even if the minimum wage level applied only to employees of certain large businesses, we would all agree that the mandated wage level would be nonsensical and counterproductive.
Now reduce the mandated wage level from an admittedly ludicrous $50 to $12.25, the level initially required by Proposition JJ. The dynamics are the same, even if not so draconian. While the mantra chanted by proponents is that JJ will force employers to pay fair wages, a more logical slogan would be, “If they won’t pay you $12.25, then go work somewhere else.”
Supporters of such a law can smugly claim that no one in Santa Monica, at least in the 100 or so businesses covered by JJ, works for less than $12.25 per hour — and they’d be right of course. The underlying reality, however, is that many who might have had an opportunity to obtain a good job with a good employer must look elsewhere, including many young people looking either for a part-time job or an opportunity to enter the work force.
What benefit is it to adopt a law which will force wage levels above those the market will pay when the result is that many will end up not working, or at least not working in Santa Monica? How is it that JJ will accomplish beneficial goals if its primary impact will be to price many low-wage workers out of the market?
A classic example of this same mentality is found in usury laws. While these laws are largely irrelevant today because of low interest rates, that has not always been the case. When market rates rise high enough to bump up against statutory limits, the result is a decrease in available credit and the inability of lower income families to obtain needed loans.
Supporters of usury laws, like those of JJ, claim they are needed to help the poor. However, the real impact on the poor is to drive them away from traditional lenders and into the arms of the loan sharks.
JJ will have a similar result — it will drive our youth and entry-level workers and those with fewer skills away from the very Santa Monica employers who provide good job opportunities and into the arms of employers outside Santa Monica, often to those less concerned about obeying laws dealing with wages and working conditions.
Obviously, this result is not the intention of JJ’s supporters. In voting on JJ, however, we are not conducting a poll on the morality of attempting to improve the quality of life for low-income families — everyone agrees with that principle. Instead we are considering a specific legislative proposal which is filled with flaws. As I said in an earlier column, good intentions do not necessarily make good laws. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a local property rights attorney.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 24, 2002. Read the original PDF.