Skip to content

Imperfections have their perfect places in life

Published:

HIP TO BE SQUARE

By CAROLINE BODKIN

Everyone has or has had a perfect friend. Remember? Think back. The friend who does no wrong. Has no wrongness.

My perfect friend was a post-airbrush beauty. She could always eat as many burgers as the boys but was forever fat-free. Her mother kept fresh cookies in the jar, wore matching sweater sets and served pizza when the gang came over on a Friday night. The perfect friend made Dance Company even though she was out of town during the auditions and perfect grades even though she missed class for student government meetings. She studied less, did better, laughed louder in a bigger circle of friends, all of whom were great if slightly less than... perfect.

I assumed so early on that no matter what she did from that moment on, it was flawless. She was the image we butted up against and secretly longed to discard. And it wasn’t just about her looking good or getting good grades, it was that she literally did no wrong. She made no mistakes. She was a circle that fit perfectly into a circular world.

As I grew, you know, into a person, I came to realize that perfect exists only as an idea. No person is perfect. We learn by mistake, we are lovable and human in our imperfections. Walking the path of variety and chance allows life to be more interesting and fulfilling than tiptoeing the tightrope.

Nice philosophy... but it didn’t keep me from wondering about her. No one’s perfect, right, right. Except her.

So, I asked, is the perfect friend happier? Has her life turned out exactly according to the perfect plan?

If you never have to go through those scary, unforeseen places on you way to self-security, are you simpler, but happier?

My time to find out came last weekend when it came time to attend my perfect friend’s wedding. My boyfriend and I were going to be back in Salt Lake City anyway, and since I’d missed many of my old friends’ weddings while I was away at school, I decided to brave the holy waters and at least swing by the reception.

Upon arrival, I could see the perfect friend had evoked the perfect wedding. Flowers and music flourished around smiles everywhere, blonde hair and bubbling old friends floated effervescently about the brightly lit, alcohol-free room in the mountain-perched Red Butte Gardens reception hall.

I grabbed my boyfriend’s hand and turned to him. I said “Darling, are you going to leave me for a perfect, sweet Mormon girl?” He laughed, kissed me on the cheek (stares from a couple onlookers) and said “No. Perfect is boring.” Yeah, right.

But all the old feelings of imperfection began to swell, and I was again the flawed friend. I sensed the girls glancing at my ring finger, naked, while shaking hands with my boyfriend, and my dress, too tight. “You’re living in LA?”

My choice of city: Dirty. My values: Foreign. Out of wedlock. Heathen. And before long it was certainly time to go, locate the origin of Perfect, say best of luck, and take off. Back to life of imperfect variety with a sigh of relief.

I scoured the room until I caught a glimpse of the white dress. I marched, yanking my date behind me. I made it through the crowd, towards the lily white folds, the folds turned, and before me stood the one and only, my perfect friend.

She gave me the biggest smile and hug I never expected.

“Caroline! You made it!” And then it happened. Perfect revealed itself and from behind her stepped a little girl in a purple dress.

“This is Theresa,” Ms. Perfect presented the child, “my little girl.”

Out of wedlock? Heathen? “Oh my,” I knelt down to the warmest small face I think I’ve ever seen. Theresa. New child. Not likely part of the perfect plan but standing there beautiful as ever. I looked up at a very happy, already mother, life-long Mormon, soon-to-be-married old friend and smiled. Then looked back down to Theresa and, without even thinking, said, “She’s perfect.” (CarolineBodkinisfarfromperfect.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 2, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe