Skip to content

In response to accusations of inaccuracies

Published:

By Tom Larmore Santa Monica

Editor: Bea Nemlaha contended in her letter published on June 25 that there are several misleading statements in a flyer recently distributed by Homeowners for Voluntary Preservation (“HVP”). However, it is her statements that are inaccurate.

First, Ms. Nemlaha disputed HVP’s statement that the Landmarks Commission can take control of your home without your consent. She states that the “Landmarks Commission controls nothing.” Try telling that to the owner of 224 18th Street who has been prevented for almost a year from demolishing an old dilapidated house solely because of the Landmarks Commission. Or the owners of 1304 Cedar Street and 249 Euclid who were threatened with structure of merit designations, escaping only after extensive vocal neighborhood opposition.

Second, Ms. Nemlaha objects to the flyer’s assertion that “all single family homes are under siege.” She asserts that only 40-year-old homes are the only ones which are ever restricted from demolition or substantial remodeling. Setting aside for a moment the fact that most homes in Santa Monica were built before 1962, a historic district affects all homes in the district, not just those with historic or architectural value.

Third, as stated in the flyer, HVP strongly believes that the Homeowners Freedom of Choice Initiative is “vital to homeowners rights and property values in our city.” Ms. Nemlaha disagrees, stating that property values have been enhanced by ordinances such as the Landmarks Ordinance and that the ordinance is no more dangerous to property rights than zoning laws.

I believe that in some areas, such as West Adams, property values have been enhanced by historic preservation laws; however, I do not agree that this will be the effect in Santa Monica. (In fact, a large sale north of Montana recently fell through solely because of the impact of the Landmarks Ordinance.) In any event, the point of the Initiative is to simply allow people to make their own choices about their homes. If historical designation will enhance property values, that argument should be made in the context of that choice, not as an excuse for allowing the city to decide what is best.

The notion that the Landmarks Ordinance is nothing more than a form of zoning is fallacious. Zoning laws apply equally to everyone, which is why courts will not permit individual parcels to be zoned differently from surrounding parcels — referred to in the law as “spot zoning.” However, this is precisely what the ordinance allows. Instead of all property owners being permitted to participate in the debate about generally applicable zoning laws, individual parcels are singled out for selected treatment.

Fourth, Ms. Nemlaha states her “understanding” that the few homeowners negatively affected financially were “small developers in for a quick-turn profit.” Whether this is relevant or not, it is not my understanding of the facts. However, the point of the Initiative is to prevent homeowners from being affected without their consent. I know several homeowners who acquired their homes many years ago and are not wealthy. The impact of the Landmarks Ordinance is that those homes will undoubtedly lose significant value if a buyer cannot be confident that the old home can be replaced by something more in keeping with modern tastes.

Of course, real estate values fluctuate with the strength of the economy, interest rates and a myriad of other factors, including zoning regulations. And of course, there are no guarantees that homes will ultimately sell for any particular price, or for even the price they might sell for today. But there is something that should be guaranteed — that certain homeowners will not be singled out for disparate treatment simply because some government agency thinks it beneficial, particularly when the risk of loss falls on the individual, not the government.

Opponents of the initiative have only one simple theme — trust us to know what’s good for you. I don’t.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 26, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe