Jokers to the left of me, jokers to the right
By Ed Silverstein
Winston Churchill said it best: “Anyone who isn’t a liberal in their 20s has no heart and anyone who isn’t a conservative in their 40s has no brain.” At 20, I could party all night and work all day: Eat fast food every day for a year and not gain enough weight for a decent lawsuit. My dreams were intact; my career filled with all things possible and my ideology remained untainted by life experience. I felt benevolent. I knew everything. Of course I was a liberal.
Having kicked and clawed my way into my 40s, for better or worse, I have arrived. My career, the third, is now a job, a necessary evil to support a lifestyle. I am into conservation … but it’s of my own diminishing energy resources. I’m sick and tired of working five months a year to pay taxes so that some politician can give it to a big donor drinking buddy or some miscreant who doesn’t want to work because, well, it’s work. I have no idea what that 20-year-old was thinking, but now, thank God, I do know everything. Of course I’m more conservative.
Actually, more like in the middle: a centrist Democrat to be exact. It’s not that I have any great love for the Democratic Party, in fact in theory I could be just as happy as a moderate Republican, but that’s in theory.
In reality the Republican Party, led by a former (read reformed) cocaine snorting, pot smoking, boozing, playboy has embraced an agenda so far to the right that Pat Buchanan is beginning to look like a liberal. Bush and his far right constituency are like a morality board uttering gasps of disapproval as they salivate over a stream of dirty movies so as to protect the rest of us from being sullied by their depravity. Their slogan should be, “Leave it to Beaver,” as they are determined to turn the clock back 50 years. To achieve this they must eschew scholarship and intellectual debate in favor of appointing sycophant advisors willing to support the entire right wing dogma no matter how badly flawed.
The president’s so-called culture of life embraces the death penalty and wants to teach abstinence-only sex education despite knowing that this will result in more teens contracting the deadly AIDS virus. Conservatives claim to adhere to religious values, but don’t seem to know the golden rule and totally skipped John 8:7 as they condemn everyone who does not conform to their narrow vision of the universe. Conservatives support school vouchers that include religious schools like the one my wife attended where she was taught that all Jews are going to hell, or conceivably madrasas that are turning out the next generation of terrorists in Pakistan.
They claim they want the government out of our lives, but they want the keys to our bedrooms. They also want the government, not trained medical professionals, to decide when and how we die, and they continue to wage a disastrous drug war that makes Vietnam look like a victory. And despite all the talk about compassionate conservatism it’s the liberals who have always showed true compassion.
There, I said the L word and despite what conservatives might think, liberal is not a dirty word. That is not to say that liberals don’t have their own set of annoying quirks. A typical conversation with a liberal would go something like: “But it doesn’t work” “But it’s the right thing to do.” “But it does-n’t work” “But it’s the right thing to do.” “BUT IT DOESN’T WORK!!!” “But it’s the right thing to do.” Sometimes you just want to slap them.
Liberals maintain death-holds on programs that succeed only as sound bites. And when a program is broken they don’t fix it; they throw more and more money at it until they make the Pentagon look like cost consultants. Liberals also support an unachievable equality rather than equal opportunity. As a result they pander to the lowest common denominator and lower expectations, rather than embracing achievement and setting the bar higher for everyone. They have left personal responsibility in the dust and kow-towed to a destructive victimization.
And liberals have become what I used to hate about conservatives … censors. Just try to have an open discussion about problems in the black community and you’ll be labeled a racist faster than you can say niggardly. Look what happened to Horowitz when he declared his opposition to slave reparations. Colleges, so called institutions of higher learning, refused to run his ads. Did they even read what he had written? I mean these people could give lessons to the Iraqi news ministry. Liberal ideologues are every bit as guilty as right wingers at closing off meaningful discussion which in turn does tremendous damage to the very people they purport to be helping.
And here’s a dirty little secret; liberals can be maddeningly condescending. When you lower standards for a single group, or when you protect one gender from a hostile work environment by creating one even more hostile, it implies that those groups are not smart enough, strong enough or capable enough to compete on an equal level. Believe me they are, and if you insist on personal responsibility, they will. Too many liberals descend from their ivory suburban towers to tell the rest of us how to live, then at the first hint of darkness, retreat to the safety of their million dollar nests to sip hundred dollar Cabernet and feel good about themselves for giving a few bucks to that poor panhandler who is that very moment shooting it into his veins, prolonging his misery and shortening his life. And remember the old adage, a conservative is nothing more than a liberal who’s been mugged.
Having gotten that off my chest, I admit that there is much to be admired in both conservative and liberal thinking, but extremism, in any form, is the antithesis of objective thought. Without that objectivity we will never have meaningful programs or solutions. It is far better to try to cherry pick the ideas that seem to be grounded in reality while retaining a modicum of compassion. Which is why I’m stuck in the middle, hopefully with you. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer splitting his time between Santa Monica and the Middle Earth. Both liberal and conservative comments will be accepted at:)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 29, 2003. Read the original PDF.