Off the fence on Iraq — no more Saddam Hussein
By Ed Silverstein
Secretary of State Colin Powell’s compelling proof of Saddam Hussein’s noncompliance with the U.N.’s resolution to disarm has finally nudged me off the fence. We need to remove this man from power. I did not come to my decision easily. I abhor war in any form and during Vietnam, I marched for peace. But this is a different kind of conflict. Vietnam did not represent a direct threat to us. Iraq does.
There are many powerful arguments against war. We are preemptively attacking a sovereign nation. There will be terrible devastation and the human toll will be great. Bush is opposed to nation building and a stable post-war Iraq would likely require a long-term commitment of U.S. troops. A war could destabilize the region and topple governments in Egypt, Saudi Arabia and other countries friendly to the United States. Saddam, if desperate, could unleash chemical and biological weapons or provide them to terrorists. Any attack on Iraq could precipitate terrorist action against America and/or our overseas interests. And then of course there is the question of President Bush’s motives.
Anyone who reads this column will know that I am not a big fan of the President’s policies and I, like Sen. McCain, believe that Bush is far too influenced by corporate interests. There is no question that Bush’s thinking must include Iraqi oil, revenge for the assassination plot against his father and even concerns about his approval rating and re-election. The “boys with toys” coalition of Rumsfeld and Cheney also have influenced the President. Both these hawks have been itching for a fight with Saddam since the last Bush presidency and had lobbied to attack Iraq in conjunction with the war in Afghanistan. However, after reading Bob Woodward’s book, “Bush At War,” I am left with the impression that Bush’s key motivation is, what you could almost call, altruistic. He has a vision (possibly grandiose) of being remembered as a President who used the might of the United States to bring about a safer world. If this is true, it is possible that North Korea, Iran or Syria could be next. Though troubling, such action may be ultimately necessary if we ever hope to live without looking over our shoulders.
Bush’s motivations aside, Iraq is a humanitarian nightmare. Saddam has no regard for human life and has killed and tortured thousands of political dissidents, starved his people, used mustard gas on the Northern Kurds and destroyed their villages. Like Hitler, he has tested chemical and biological weapons on people he has imprisoned. I believe the United States as well as the rest of the world has a moral responsibility to guard against atrocities from whatever quarter. And while any war will result in serious casualties, there is likely to be more innocent lives lost if we do nothing, not to mention the potential for this conflict to escalate dramatically.
Even if you question the evidence presented by Powell concerning al Qaeda’s Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi, there is no question that Saddam has aided terrorism. His funneling of large cash payments to the family of each suicide bomber targeting Israel has been, in part, responsible for the thousands of innocent deaths on both sides of the conflict, many of them young children.
There is another factor to consider. Although the war could spark further resentment throughout the region, the Middle East has traditionally respected strength and an attack on Iraq might send a powerful message to other countries that sponsor terrorism. Syria, for example, supports the terrorist group Hizballah. A recent New Republic article reported that Hizballah is more organized and better financed than al Qaeda, and there is evidence that the group is shifting sights from exclusively attacking Israel to including U.S. targets as well.
There are some who believe we can continue to contain Iraq; that his weapons of mass destruction don’t represent a threat because he does not have the means to deliver them. This is naive. Our very presence, such as the no-fly zones that have allowed the Kurds to rebuild and begin to prosper, has increased tensions in the region. If Saddam is not removed we will have to patrol those zones indefinitely. Sooner or later this, along with the suffering of the Iraqi people due to sanctions, will cause unrest to boil over. This will take down several friendly governments causing the U.S. a far greater problem. Furthermore, Saddam does have a delivery system for his weapons … terrorists. Chemical and biological weapons can easily be concealed and deployed. It is even possible for terrorists to infect themselves with deadly viruses and bring them into the country. We cannot ignore the terrifying possibility that a war with Iraq might cause Hussein to unleash the very weapons we are trying to prevent or even, as Scott Layne and Michael Sommer suggest in their LA Times editorial, cause a “Bio-Armageddon.” But we also have to be aware that, if left unchecked, the weapons will only become more dangerous. Sooner or later Saddam might use them to dominate the region and it is almost certain that they will fall into the hands of terrorists either through Saddam’s participation or through a corrupt or extremist Iraqi official.
On a purely practical note, without Saddam, sanctions could be lifted. The Iraqi oil could be used to provide the people of Iraq with a better life and it will help keep the price of oil stable. This will be of particular importance if, (or, as many experts believe, when) Saudi Arabia’s leadership is toppled and the U.S. is deprived of 8 percent of its oil. Without Iraqi oil, the United States could face financial devastation from skyrocketing oil prices.
One thing is for sure, the inspections have been a dismal failure and it is pointless to go on with the charade, even in light of a few stalling concessions from Saddam. It would be my sincere hope that any action against Iraq be U.N. ordained and executed by a coalition force, but that seems in doubt. The U.N. appears to be intent on making itself as irrelevant as it is in its handling of the Israel/Palestinian conflict. With its reaction to Powell’s speech and obstruction to NATO’s preparation of Turkey, France has surrendered its credibility. The motivations of the other dissenters are equally questionable. Sixty-some odd years ago, Europe and the United States were reluctant to confront Hitler’s Germany and it resulted in a war that killed millions. If we don’t confront Hussein and others like him, it could result in a biological agent that could wipe out a billion.
War in any form is one of man’s most deplorable creations and it is never an action that should be entered into lightly. But the world has changed and the potential for present and future horrors has never been so dire. If we don’t act now, we might not live to regret it. (Ed Silverstein is freelance writer (who wants to go on living) in Santa Monica. Comments may be e-mailed to: )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 12, 2003. Read the original PDF.