Israel shouldn’t squander high road opportunity
By Ed Silverstein
Nearly obscured by the cloud of war, Dr. Mahmoud Abbas, who also is more commonly known as Abu Mazen, has accepted the post of Palestinian Prime Minister. Abu Mazen, credited by many as the architect of the Oslo accords, is a highly intellectual man and is considered to be a pragmatist and a moderate. Mazen has publicly declared the current intifada a disaster for his people and their goal of autonomy, and has called for a halt to Palestinian armed attacks.
Mazen’s appointment offers the best chance to end the 30 month-old Israeli/Palestinian conflict. It also provides a rare opportunity for Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. But in order to gain political advantage, Sharon must act quickly and preemptively.
Sharon should immediately embrace Mazen as the new leader of the Palestinian people. More importantly, the Israeli Prime Minister should announce a unilateral end to the violence and offer a schedule for the rapid and ordered pull-out from all the occupied regions. By instituting proactive measures now, rather than waiting for a negotiated settlement down the road, Sharon, who is viewed by much of the world as an unyielding aggressor, could greatly improve his political standing and that of his country. If Sharon does nothing and peace is later achieved, Mazen will likely receive most of the credit.
An Israeli initiated pull-out would have many other beneficial consequences. By ceasing hostilities it would marginalize Arafat and would bolster Israel’s claim that Arafat has been the major obstacle to peace. A secondary benefit would be to strengthen support for Mazen. This could help allow the new Prime Minister to appoint others into his government with similar views and minimize interference from Arafat. Such an action by Israel also has the potential to provide cover for moderate Palestinians looking for a way to condemn terrorism and support peace.
The United States would greatly profit from any movement toward a resolution in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, which most Arabs consider the Middle East’s single most important issue. Such a move would help soften opposition to the U.S. Iraqi invasion and somewhat curtail the Arab media’s continuous onslaught of anti-American rhetoric.
Israel is also a victim of the constant barrage of anti-Israel propaganda by the Arab media and the United Nations. Through 1989, the U.N. Security Council has passed 97 resolutions condemning Israel out of a total of 175. Only four resolutions went against all Arab countries combined, including the Palestinians. Under these attacks, American support for Israel is showing the first signs of strain. Despite Israel being our staunchest ally and the only democratic government in the region, there are those who have begun to question the continued expenditure of billions in aid.
Another problem for Israel is the tragic death of Rachel Corrie. Corrie, an American peace activist, was run over and killed when she lost her footing while standing in front of an oncoming bulldozer. The incident, which Israel claims was a terrible accident, threatens to become a public relations disaster. A move toward peace could help diminish the credibility of the strident voices against Israel and focus attention away from Corrie.
The United Nations (or whatever is left of it) would be forced to take a more favorable stance toward Israel. Any Palestinian suicide attack subsequent to a pull out would compel the U.N.’s condemnation or risk, lending credence to Israel’s claim that the organization is, at best, negatively biased against Israel, at worst blatantly anti-Semitic. Any such miscarriage would also support the notion that the U.N. (along with France) has become increasingly irrelevant as a world arbiter and human rights advocate. The same would hold true, albeit to a far lessor extent, for the Arab league. An attack would also test Mazen’s opposition to terrorism and his resolve as a Palestinian leader.
No matter what Mazen’s appointment brings, it is apparent to any sane human being that it is imperative for the Israeli/Palestinian conflict to end. Aside from the terrible human toll suffered by both sides, the conflict has destabilized the region and is the root of tremendous anti-American sentiment.
If the Palestinian’s are to ever have their own country and if the Israelis are ever to again feel safe in theirs, both sides must be willing to compromise. Even more crucial is a courageous leader.
Such a man was Anwar Sadat. The Egyptian leader took an incredible gamble to secure peace with Israel and eventually paid the ultimate price. Arafat, even when offered unheard of concessions by Israel, turned his back on peace. President Bush fumbled his chance when he embraced isolationism over continued diplomacy. With Mazen’s appointment we may finally have a light at the end of the tunnel. We can only hope that Sharon will see that light and seize the initiative.
ASIDE: To those “peace” protesters who have been throwing rocks and steel rebar at police officers — you just don’t get it. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments and general whining can be e-mailed to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 26, 2003. Read the original PDF.