Charging an 87-year-old driver is an outrage, an injustice
By Ed Silverstein
In a colossal miscarriage of justice, the LA County District Attorney is charging Russell Weller with 10 counts of felony vehicular manslaughter. These extremely harsh charges stem from the incident in which 10 pedestrians were killed and an additional 63 injured when the 87-year-old driver lost control of his car and sped through the crowded Santa Monica Farmers’ Market last summer.
Certainly the families of the victims and those injured want their pound of flesh. But is this a crime that should be prosecuted?
What we know for sure is that Weller rear-ended a Mercedes, then accelerated into the market, reaching speeds of 60 miles an hour. His Buick LeSabre smashed through the crowds for nearly two blocks before bodies and debris caused the car to come to a stop.
Weller was not charged with hit and run or leaving the scene of an accident, which seems to be the only legitimate excuse for charging him with a crime. Rather, he was charged gross criminal negligence because he reached unsafe speeds and never applied the brakes.
The authorities concur that what most likely occurred was when Weller hit the Mercedes, he tried to slam on the brakes, but instead hit the gas pedal. So why did-n’t he hit the brakes?
Imagine that you are Weller. You’re in an accident. You hit the brakes and unaccountably the car shoots forward. Your first frenzied thought might be that the brakes aren’t working or the accelerator has become stuck. The instinct is to jam harder on the brake pedal, but in this case you’re actually pushing the accelerator. Add to this the violent impacts and horror of crashing through the crowd, and you begin to understand why Weller might have lacked the presence of mind to correct his error.
According to experts, it is not uncommon in pedal misapplication situations, as this is called, to travel for 10 or more seconds before the driver realizes his mistake — more than enough time to accelerate to the 60 miles per hour reached by the Buick.
The fact that Weller was 86 years old may very well have been a contributing factor. A man of his advanced age would have a significantly slower reaction time and the potential for increased confusion. Some say he should be held accountable because he was aware that his age made him unfit to drive.
But even if this is true, it is the California state legislators that are guilty of gross negligence. Our representatives are all too aware that Americans are getting older, living longer and becoming more dangerous on the road. No one denies that more rigorous and comprehensive testing of older drivers is desperately needed, yet they refuse to act because they are wary of arousing the ire of senior voters.
But even if Weller is potentially guilty of a crime it makes little sense to prosecute him.
Weller has led a previously exemplary life and does not represent a threat to society. He will never drive again so he is not a future threat to others.
Weller’s prosecution will be a media circus requiring expensive security and attorney man-hours for news conferences and press briefings. If the county prevails and Weller receives the maximum sentence of 18 years, which he has virtually no chance surviving even a fraction of, the costs of incarcerating an 87-year-old with poor health would be prohibitive.
There are some who feel that he deserves to be punished for what he’s done, even if it was an accident. But what more can be done to this man? His life is ruined. Civil suits will rob him of any wealth he has accumulated. His reputation and good name, built with a lifetime of good deeds and charity, has been obliterated. His health has deteriorated drastically. His remaining days will be spent sick, destitute, wracked by guilt and shame, and devoid of any joy.
In fact, putting this extremely elderly man through the stressful ordeal of a trial might very well be a death sentence. This would constitute a cruel and unusual punishment, particularly if he were innocent.
So why are we prosecuting tragedies? Part of it is because of the out-of-control litigation. Already Santa Monica has been named in numerous lawsuits. If Weller is found guilty of criminal negligence, the city could argue it does not bear responsibility for not having barricades. Another answer is overly aggressive prosecutors looking to make a name for themselves. Cases such as these are sensational and attract an increasingly tabloid press.
Finally, we as a society have become intolerant of misfortune. We feel a need to assign blame for everything. But as is often the case, tragedies spring from a series of events that cannot be foreseen and are not the fault of anyone.
Such was the case with Russell Weller. And to prosecute a good man who was a victim of tragic circumstances only creates another tragedy. (Ed Silverstein lives in Santa Monica and shops at the Farmers’ Market. Comments can be e-mailed at).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.