By Marc Sanschagrin Santa Monica
Francois Khoury’s contention that Kurt Peterson’s latest effort was an angry diatribe, struck me, as well... an angry diatribe.
If we are going to have an intelligent debate on the issue of a living wage in Santa Monica, what we first need to do is separate the apples from the oranges — not insult the opposition.
Francois is management. Not surprisingly, he sees management’s point of view. Kurt is a union organizer. That is the point of view from which he sees best.
Francois did a nice job of summarizing the advantages of workers remaining nonunion; they don’t have to pay dues, follow union by-laws and so on. Fair enough.
As a teacher I’ve long thought we’ve done a poor job in this country of teaching our children of just how normal came to mean a five-day, 40-hour week. Having read my history I know full well that prior to the advent of unions in this country workers had the right to work 16-hour days, six days a week, without health care of any sort, no vacations, no sick days and so on and so forth. These advantages were often shared with women and children as young as 10 years old.
You may argue, if you like, that unions’ days have come and gone, but you cannot argue but that they have significantly altered the landscape for the better when it comes to working conditions. And those who doubt what management does unfettered by the counterweight of the collective bargaining system need look no farther than their history books for examples. I’d suggest starting with the Triangle Building fire in New York...
Last time I read economics (Adam Smith’s, The Wealth of Nations), the duty of management was to the bottom line — profits. The duty of the union was to its members. Sure, some individuals can cut themselves a fine deal with the boss, but what about the rest? Can they walk in and demand justice on their own? With a union they can, and they can do it on their feet rather than their knees.
P.S. It should be noted that as a teacher, I, like my nearly three million colleagues nationwide are members of state associations like CTA, and either NEA or AFT nationally.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 11, 2002. Read the original PDF.