By LEGAL VIEWS AND NEWS By David Pisarra
The bright new world of the Internet means access for many people to new opportunities and new ventures. It means that you can start and build a business with a computer, a camera and some yard sale steals, thanks to companies like E- Bay, Yahoo, OnlineSales and U-bid.
I have clients who are making thousands of dollars using the Internet as a legitimate business for the sale of collectibles, services and consumer goods. One of my clients specializes in women’s handbags. Another in luxury automobiles.
What these and all the others are doing, besides making themselves self-sufficient, is opening themselves up to lawsuits throughout the United States.
In the confusing world of law, known as litigation, there is a basic concept called “jurisdiction,” which each plaintiff must tell the court exists before a lawsuit can proceed to the fun times like discovery, depositions, hearings and trials.
It is one of those obscure little things that can either save a defendant from having to defend a lawsuit or make a plaintiff very happy because now they can move forward with their suit. As a procedural matter, it is usually a very basic item.
What it means is that the court has the right to drag this defendant into court and make them defend themselves. It is based on the United States Constitution and on a state’s individual constitution as to when, where and how a plaintiff may sue a defendant.
Of course, two people (or companies) located in the same state may always sue each other, but what happens when one of them or a company is located in another state? The U.S. Supreme Court has determined that a state may exercise jurisdiction over a defendant in two ways. They can either list the grounds over which they will take jurisdiction, or the more common and easier way is to have a jurisdictional rule which allows a plaintiff to exercise jurisdiction over a defendant so long as it would be allowed by the U.S. Constitution.
Well, what the heck does that mean? It means that if a defendant has specifically entered into a state to do business there, then that state can take jurisdiction over the defendant for that business relationship. It seems difficult, but it really makes sense.
If you as a California resident advertise TVs in Texas newspapers and have a Texas phone number that forwards to California and you sell a defective TV to a Texan, you should be sued in Texas. You cannot argue that you shouldn’t be sued there because you are a California resident who has never been in the state of Texas. It just wouldn’t be fair.
So what does this have to do with Internet businesses?
One of the great things about the Internet is that it allows us to access people, places and things, across the globe. The beauty of this is that I can put a picture of my 1990 BMW or my great aunt Martha’s mink stole on a web page located in a computer somewhere in the Silicon Valley and sell it to Dixie in Texas. And we never have to meet in person.
But here is where it gets tricky. If Dixie doesn’t like the BMW, or she finds that I misrepresented the condition of the mink stole, where is she going to sue me? She wants to sue me in Texas because it is close to her home. Her lawyer comes over for dinner and she doesn’t have to travel.
I, on the other hand do not want to be defending myself in a Texas courtroom. It means I have to hire a Texas lawyer, travel there for any depositions, hearings or trials. I want to argue that because I only advertised on the Internet, which is physically located in the state of California, that it is unfair and unconstitutional to sue me in Texas. Anything that is unconstitutional is not allowed.
Well so far, the U.S. Supreme Court has not ruled clearly on the Internet jurisdiction issue. However, several states have ruled that it is constitutional for them to exercise jurisdiction over a defendant who sold goods over the Internet, based on the Supreme Court’s prior rulings and “purposeful availment” of the marketplace.
What that says is if I use the Internet to market goods and I later actually sell those goods to a person in another state — when I have had contact with that person over the Internet — I have opened myself to being sued in their state.
Here’s a real life example. I have a client who is an auto broker in Hawaii. He sold a car in Hawaii by way of an E-Bay ad. The car was inspected in Hawaii by the buyer’s agent and the money was transferred to a Hawaii bank account. Then the car was shipped to a California address. The buyer is not happy with the car. The question is “should the California buyer sue the Hawaii broker in California or Hawaii?”
Since the sale occurred over the Internet and the buyer is in California, courts are going to take jurisdiction over the case. The Hawaii car dealer has to hire a California lawyer to defend this lawsuit.
So if you are doing business over the Internet, selling goods to people out of state, be prepared to defend a lawsuit in another state if your goods don’t match what you represent them to be, or if the deal goes south. (David Pisarra is a partner in the Santa Monica law firm of Pisarra & Grist. He welcomes questions and (310) 664-9969 or e-mailed at).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 29, 2003. Read the original PDF.