By JODI SUMMERS
The Internal Revenue Service has an intriguing new gift for property owners, an evolution of tax code sections 1031 and 121. New guidelines have been adopted allowing investors who move and use their old home as a rental property to eventually “buy down” and take cash out of the deal without facing federal income tax liability. This is an amazingly progressive step by the IRS because this money — known as “boot” in tax circles — had previously been taxed.
The “like-kind” exchange rules of IRS Section 1031 allow individuals and corporations to trade in existing business and investment property for new property of equal or greater value — and defer the capital gains tax along the way.
IRS code Section 121 lets you exclude $250,000 of gain if you file a single return and up to $500,000 excluded if you file a joint return when you sell your personal residence if you have lived there for two of the last five years.
“For the first time, the IRS is allowing taxpayers to mix the rules on principal residences and investment property,” notes Rob Keasal, an accountant and real estate tax specialist. “The new rules do not apply to all 1031 exchanges, only those that feature the use of a taxpayer’s former primary residence.”
What gives this new guideline so much appeal is that for the first time, taxpayers are allowed to take cash tax-free out of a property exchange. The new rule is retroactive to Jan. 27, 2005.
The new primary home-investment possibility provided by the IRS that includes depreciation deductions goes something like this: Marcel purchased a house in Las Vegas for $210,000 and lived there from 1999 until 2003. Then he moved to Los Angeles, settled into a relationship and bought a new house, where he now lives. Meanwhile, Marcel is renting out his home in Las Vegas, and claims depreciation deductions of $20,000.
Realizing he wants to invest near home, he does a 1031 exchange, paying $460,000 for a loft in downtown LA that he plans to lease out. He takes $10,000 in cash from the deal to feed his hobbies.
Since Marcel’s adjusted basis is $190,000 ($210,000 minus $20,000 in depreciation deductions), he realizes a gain of $280,000. Marcel applies the primary residence rule (Section 121) first to exclude $250,000 of the $280,000 gain before applying the non-recognition rules of Section 1031. He may defer the remaining gain of $30,000, including the $20,000 attributable to depreciation, under Section 1031.
Marcel recognizes no gain for the $10,000 boot because boot is taken into account only to the extent it exceeds the amount of the gain excluded under Section 121. Marcel’s basis in the replacement property is $430,000, which is equal to the basis of the relinquished property at the time of the exchange ($190,000) increased by the gain excluded under Section 121 ($250,000), and reduced by the cash Marcel receives ($10,000).
The terms of this new ruling state that you first apply as much of the gain as you need to maximize the Section 121 gain, with the balance applied to the Section 1031 gain. Traditionally, if a seller received cash or property that is not like-kind property in an exchange that otherwise qualifies as a like-kind exchange, the taxpayer is required to pay capital gains tax on the boot.
Prior to this current IRS ruling, the like-kind exchange rules did not apply to property that is used solely as a personal residence.
Another new and exciting aspect of this new rule is that property owners can use this exclusion once every two years. This is beneficial if you are confident that your home is going to rapidly appreciate in the next few years and, you can afford to use your family home as a rental property. Perhaps its time for that sabbatical in Europe?
If you can afford to keep your primary residence as a rental — and you feel you neighborhood is going to appreciate — speak with your tax advisor about the new guidelines. (Jodi Summers is director of the investment division at Boardwalk Realty Santa Monica. Contact her at, or call (310) 309-4219.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 30, 2005. Read the original PDF.