By INCITES By Ed Silverstein
It rises from the deepest depths of the mercury-tainted oceans and up a mighty river past the decaying corpses of recent fish kills. It slips into a tributary and meanders against the current until, confronted by debris dumped from a coal strip mine, it is forced upon the land.
Onward it slogs through pristine wet-lands/condo developments, then veers onto the scar of a new logging road that has been ripped through a thinned forest. All at once it ascends, climbing past oil wells piercing the Arctic wilderness, up over the tallest mountain peaks until it is soaring through the brown smudged atmosphere and into the depleted ozone layer.
And we wonder, is it a bird, a plane, a trial balloon? No, it is Ralph Nader’s ego.
“Just Ralph,” as I like to call him, has announced he is considering yet another tragic run for the Presidency. It is likely that he will be the candidate for the Green party who, according to their Web site, is committed to environmentalism, non-violence, social justice, universal health care, eliminating corporate globalization, alternative energy, election reform and decent wages for workers.
But it is obvious that the Green Party can’t see the clear-cut forest through the trees. Their candidate’s 2000 run did nothing but make the grass GREENer for the other side and browner for everyone else. By splitting the progressive vote, Nader handed the Presidency to George Bush whose only commitment is to his big-money corporate contributors.
The Bush Administration has created the absolute worst-case scenario for the environment. Bush has denied global warming, obliterated environmental protections, weakened regulatory bodies and stacked the courts with hundreds of anti-environmental judges. Alternative energy is a non-starter and universal health care will never see the light of day unless it becomes another corporate giveaway.
Further, his administration has pursued violent, preemptive confrontations justified with lies and shifting rationalizations. The rich have realized enormous benefits on the backs of the poor, minorities and those with physical and mental handicaps. His administration has trashed civil rights, embraced globalization and eroded decent wages and benefits through union-busting schemes and shifting well-paying civil-service positions into lesser private-sector jobs.
Of course, “Just Ralph” doesn’t accept any responsibility for this mayhem. According to the Jolly Green Giant of the Green Party, there is no difference between Democrats and Republicans. Nader also claims his candidacy had nothing to do with Gore losing the election— proving yet again that denial is not confined to users of miracle-diet supplements and the psychic-network hotline.
The fact is that Nader’s candidacy garnered nearly 3 percent of the vote and cost the Democrats New Hampshire and Florida. Either one of those states would have been enough to have propelled Gore into the White House and given the rest of us a kinder, gentler nation.
To be fair, Nader’s run in 2000 could be written off as naiveté. Bush had claimed he would be the type of president to pursue a non-partisan agenda. And there had been some hope that Nader’s candidacy might garner the necessary 5 percent of the vote to qualify the Greens for matching election funds. But that veil of innocence has been lifted.
A second term for Bush, without the concerns of being reelected and with the potential to replace up to three Supreme Court Justices as well as hundreds of federal judges, could spell disaster for progressive values for decades. And what “Just Ralph” seems to be ignoring is that once you build on wetlands they are gone forever. Endangered animals that lose protections could very well disappear from the face of the earth. And with a horde of anti-regulatory/pro-business judges in place, workers and consumers will lose the very consumer protections championed by Nader himself.
Nader’s candidacy will siphon off just enough votes to condemn the already-slim prospects of the Democratic candidate. It is also likely that many of the Green party’s votes from 2000 will defect to the Democrats. This will irreparably damage the Greens’ credibility and prove they are not ready for prime time in the national arena. Even Ronnie Dugger, who presented Nader at the two previous Green Party conventions, felt compelled to write an article for “The Nation” magazine titled “Ralph Don’t Run.” But “Just Ralph” doesn’t seem to be listening.
For Nader to run in 2004 can only be construed as an act of extraordinary hubris from a monumental ego or ideological dogma that is so unflinching that it has blinded the candidate to the devastation he has wreaked upon the party’s core principles and the world.
What separates progressives is the willingness to put the needs of others ahead their own desires. And it’s time for Nader to do just that. ■Author’s Note: Since this column was written, Nader has declared that it is unlikely he will run as a Green due to a dispute with the party. He is, however, still contemplating an equally disastrous run as an Independent and will make a final decision by the end of this month). (Ed Silverstein is a free-lance writer who splits his time living in green though very unGreen Montana and the browner, though very Green, Santa Monica. Comments can be sent to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 7, 2004. Read the original PDF.