Is Santa Monica due for a big real estate bust or is this for now, largely a big fiction? I don’t know how many of you have read John Steinbeck’s classic novel the “Grapes of Wrath” and you might recall the poor Joad family. Or you might have seen the motion picture version? For me all this talk of a California real estate “bust” and the associative imagery that gets conjured up can weigh hard on the mind, especially if you’ve got any kind of historic awareness of the economics involved. When I hear about how some economists predict a coming real estate crash my thoughts return to the Joads and the dust bowl days. Well, I’m not ready to jump on the back of a flat bed truck and head off for better pastures with the devastated Joad family, but that’s just about how you feel after reading some of today’s doomsday proclamations making the rounds in all the business editorials.
You hear from the “irrational exuberance” shouting economists that the situation is dire in home ownership real estate here in California and on the East Coast from Boston to South Florida, and they say that prices may come crashing down with a big loud thud. These forecasters of glum like to point to the stock market retreat beginning in March of 2000 and say that if it can happen with that “bust” it can happen in real estate. But where was the big thud in the supposedly 2000 crash? I did-n’t hear it. Seems like we are on our way back to a recovery fairly soon after that supposed crash. Well, it might be going a little too slow over the last several days and weeks for some folks, but this is not the second Great Depression that so many economists thought might follow on the turn-of-the-century stock market downturn.
Overall productivity remains at historic high levels. The stock market is always on the move and we might be entering a period of caution due to high energy costs, but that is no reason to grab everything you can in five minutes and then head out the door. A Great Depression happening again here in America would put up to 30 percent of the workers out on the streets and even that did not happen in Japan’s real estate crash of more than a decade ago. And our real estate prices would probably have to increase by a factor of seven to match the great Japanese price heights.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 17, 2005. Read the original PDF.